[sprig]

username -- sprig
buttermilk’s name/link -- Penelope (on mobile so I can’t link but link in my dog <3)
choice -- perhaps she wandered off?
day -- one

[Niluna]

username -- niluna
buttermilk’s name/link -- Cassie
choice -- perhaps she wandered off
day -- 1

[Bayfire213]

username -- klovesugar2
buttermilk’s name/link -- Atlas
choice -- “I don't see any signs of a scuffle... Perhaps she just, well, wandered off?” Ears flicking unsurely, a bull with creamy golden fur akin to the hue of the warm sand beneath his hooves peered around, his gentle gaze like liquid chocolate, even while pensively studying the area in which the avian was supposedly last seen.
day -- 1

Edited because I forgot to add the day.

[parlaymars]

x
username -- qunari.
buttermilk’s name/link -- blaise
choice -- perhaps she wandered off
day -- 1

[womp womp]

username -- diamond sapphire
buttermilk’s name/link -- bluebell
choice -- perhaps she wandered off
day -- 1

[Knickknacks]

username -- Knickknacks
buttermilk’s name/link -- Bluebell
choice -- “If I had to guess, I’d say she probably wandered off,” Bluebell mused, scanning the area with a curious gaze, as though searching for telltale tracks.
day -- 1

[Northstar.]

username -- Northstar.
buttermilk’s name/link -- Nalu
choice -- maybe something took her?
day -- 1

[bluex]

username — bluex
buttermilk’s name/link —Avalon
choice — Avalon eyes light up at the thought of an adventure. Looking around, he can’t notice anything out of the ordinary.
“I don’t know, perhaps she just wondered off?”
day — 1

[Desmond]

username -- Desmond
buttermilk’s name/link -- Takara
choice -- Perhaps something took her?
day -- 1

[mars]

username -- ➳ palla
buttermilk’s name/link -- pippin
choice -- maybe something took her?
day -- 1