[Sculi the Ax]

i know who did it!

username //
SCULIAX
jbd name //

answer //
Ducky
reason //
I'll just show my work XD:

Snaps: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver.[strike]Limonade did it."
Ducky: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. The other jbds are all passing the buck."
Vegi: "I am innocent. I never saw Guppy before. Limonade is guilty."
Limonade: "I am innocent. Guppy is the guilty man. Snaps lied when she said I did it."
Guppy: "I did not kill Shibakisses. Ducky is the guilty man. Vegi and I are old pals."

I crossed off each false statement, here are the reasons why I crossed them off:
Guppy: Vegi said he never saw Guppy before
Limonade: One of Guppy's true statements was "I did not kill Shibakisses" - he is innocent
Vegi: Limonade cannot be the murderer, else she would only have one true statement
Snaps: Limonade cannot be the murderer, else she would only have one true statement
Ducky: Guppy it was one of Guppy's truths

XD[/strike]

Darn, just missed it, oh well, CONGRATS! <3333

[Sphye]

One question... Every suspect has been mentioned. One of them is right, I'm guessing? Are you judging based on the reason we chose the suspect? or only if we have the right answer?

reason (;

but guys, we have a winner!

i know who did it!

username // Sphie
jbd name // Painted Truth
answer // Ducky did it.
reason //

Snaps: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. Limonade did it."
Ducky: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. The other jbds are all passing the buck."
Vegi: "I am innocent. I never saw Guppy before. Limonade is guilty."
Limonade: "I am innocent. Guppy is the guilty man. Snaps lied when she said I did it."
Guppy: "I did not kill Shibakisses. Ducky is the guilty man. Vegi and I are old pals."

Starting with Limonade: The lie is that Guppy is guilty, because otherwise there would be multiple killers. Guppy and Limonade are both innocent.
Vegi's statement that Limonade is guilty is now false. This means that Vegi never saw Guppy before, making Guppy's statement, "Vegi and I are old pals" false. Ducky is now guilty.

this is the correct answer AND reasoning!
thanks for playing guys (;

Oh my gosh, I won?! I am so surprised, I though someone else would guess before me. Thank you so much!

[emberonis]

Congrats. :3 I'm useless at riddles... I hope that you enjoy your new bean and take great care of her. :3

[~Vanilla~]

congrats!!! that riddling went super fast! take care of your new bean <3

[kittu]

lol Nice

Shiba you should make another c: That was fun

[Dewey]

I stink at riddles, but I was stalking. c:

Congratulations Sphie, take good care of her! <3

[luthor]

Congrats Sphie ! c:
I was trying to figure it out but i got extremely confused xD

[Solarizing]

i know who did it!

username // SolarDaemon
jbd name // Glade
answer // Snaps murdered Shibakisses.
reason // Ducky said that the other JBDs were "passing the buck". To "pass the buck" means to blame others, or something along that line. This was proven when Snaps accused Limonade of killing Shibakisses. Since this is true, one other thing must be false. But if not killing Shibakisses was false, how could Ducky have murdered her, as he didn't own a revolver and Shibakisses was shot? Therefore Ducky is innocent. Because of that, I now know that Guppy was lying when he said that Ducky was the guilty man. This makes Guppy's other two statements true; he and Vegi are old pals, and he is innocent. Since they're friends, that means that Vegi's statement about not knowing Guppy is false. His other two statements are then true; he is innocent and Limonade is guilty. However, looking at Limonade's statement, since Guppy isn't guilty, then he is innocent and Snaps lied. If Snaps lied then his third statement is false, and he is the proven murderer.

Congratulations ^_^

[sundance,]

Ahhhh!! Why did you tell me?! I wanted to figure it out myself! Oh well Congratz sooo much!

[Charchar2]

I was trying to figure out what "passing the buck" meant xD