[quitting¿]

i know who did it!

username //
Furriesforever
jbd name //
Lily Blossom
answer //
~~Snaps~reason //
Beacuse he says
Snaps: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. Limonade did it."And limonade says she was guilty and he LIED!so woulden't that make hi stsament false?

[Pure Dragon]

I want to solve the riddle (sucker for riddles here xD) and the JBD is beautiful, but not really my type. If I gave the answer to one of my friends who wants it, would that be considered cheating?

[kittu]

Wow O.o Lots of Veiwers XD

sorry didnt see the no edit part put the original answer back
if thats alright Ill leave the original I love this JBD X3

[callmefearless]

i know who did it!

username // shattered.
jbd name // Skaer
answer // Ducky
reason // though being acussed of the murder he is the only one who did not acuse one of teh other JBD's

[hawkeye;]

i know who did it!

username // hawkeye;
jbd name // Rosiex
answer // Vegi
reason // No one blamed Vegi. Which means that vegi probably didn't do it

[Sphye]

i know who did it!

username // Sphie
jbd name // Painted Truth
answer // Ducky did it.
reason //

Snaps: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. Limonade did it."
Ducky: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. The other jbds are all passing the buck."
Vegi: "I am innocent. I never saw Guppy before. Limonade is guilty."
Limonade: "I am innocent. Guppy is the guilty man. Snaps lied when she said I did it."
Guppy: "I did not kill Shibakisses. Ducky is the guilty man. Vegi and I are old pals."

Starting with Limonade: The lie is that Guppy is guilty, because otherwise there would be multiple killers. Guppy and Limonade are both innocent.
Vegi's statement that Limonade is guilty is now false. This means that Vegi never saw Guppy before, making Guppy's statement, "Vegi and I are old pals" false. Ducky is now guilty.

[sundance,]

One question... Every suspect has been mentioned. One of them is right, I'm guessing? Are you judging based on the reason we chose the suspect? or only if we have the right answer?

[~Vanilla~]

i know who did it!

username // ~Vanilla~
jbd name // Scribbles
answer // Snaps had done it!
reason // Snaps mentioned a revolver, a specific gun, they might have not owned a revolver but they did somehow get a hold of on and shot Shibakisses

[shibuki]

One question... Every suspect has been mentioned. One of them is right, I'm guessing? Are you judging based on the reason we chose the suspect? or only if we have the right answer?

reason (;

but guys, we have a winner!

i know who did it!

username // Sphie
jbd name // Painted Truth
answer // Ducky did it.
reason //

Snaps: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. Limonade did it."
Ducky: "I did not kill Shibakisses. I never owned a revolver. The other jbds are all passing the buck."
Vegi: "I am innocent. I never saw Guppy before. Limonade is guilty."
Limonade: "I am innocent. Guppy is the guilty man. Snaps lied when she said I did it."
Guppy: "I did not kill Shibakisses. Ducky is the guilty man. Vegi and I are old pals."

Starting with Limonade: The lie is that Guppy is guilty, because otherwise there would be multiple killers. Guppy and Limonade are both innocent.
Vegi's statement that Limonade is guilty is now false. This means that Vegi never saw Guppy before, making Guppy's statement, "Vegi and I are old pals" false. Ducky is now guilty.

this is the correct answer AND reasoning!
thanks for playing guys (;

[Charchar2]

i know who did it!

username // Charchar2
jbd name // Hibiscus
answer // It was none of them.
reason // If you think anyone did, each has at least two false statements, not two truths and one lie.