The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Spine]

Would this be fair? I'm really not good with bulk trades.

I'm not sure but it may seem unfair on my side??

im not the best with it either but in my opinion, i personally would not take it.

[lovehunter~]

Thoughts on this?
I know the sitting cat they're offering has an ok demand, but fairness wise I'm not sure.

Its not very fair, i'm pretty sure your pet is on the list! Get a second opinion, I see those robot cat store pets go for a lot more

[SeaCrest]

Would this be fair? I'm really not good with bulk trades.

I'm not sure but it may seem unfair on my side??

Absolutely not. It's extremely unfair to the bottom - if we assume that the unknown '19 pets will be common, the top adds up to less than half of a '14 rare, while the bottom adds up to 7.5 '14 rares. This is because the bottom includes a '11 and a '12 uncommon. The top has so many OMGSC and VC pets that it barely makes a difference.

[SeaCrest]

Thoughts on this?
I know the sitting cat they're offering has an ok demand, but fairness wise I'm not sure.

Its not very fair, i'm pretty sure your pet is on the list! Get a second opinion, I see those robot cat store pets go for a lot more

The robot cat is not on the list, but as a '14 store pet it goes for an early '09 rare. I would say it's unfair given that Redtail was an extended release through April 2010, making it only worth a mid '10 rare without demand. Warrior cat demand is pretty good, though not as good alone as it would be in a set or partial set. I personally wouldn't take it.

[Pheara]

Would this be fair? I'm really not good with bulk trades.

I'm not sure but it may seem unfair on my side??

Absolutely not. It's extremely unfair to the bottom - if we assume that the unknown '19 pets will be common, the top adds up to less than half of a '14 rare, while the bottom adds up to 7.5 '14 rares. This is because the bottom includes a '11 and a '12 uncommon. The top has so many OMGSC and VC pets that it barely makes a difference.

Thank you! I thought so, I'm the button one.

[Redpanda]

Haven’t really gotten a correct? evaluation of how this could be made fair/ is it fair?

And i’ve gotten 2 opposite opinions on this, could I get one more?

I’d like opinions on this one if possible

thank you in advance

[lilpupin]

Is this fair? I'm guessing not? Thank you for any help in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83872268&userid=833434&signature=R2UNH-dxLg3feqaZ47hBPw

[SeaCrest]

Is this fair? I'm guessing not? Thank you for any help in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83872268&userid=833434&signature=R2UNH-dxLg3feqaZ47hBPw

This is very much unfair the top. The top adds up to just over 2.5 2011 rares, the bottom only adds up to 1.5 2013 rare.

[emburs]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83899307&userid=915355&signature=Wpax2rsAGsZsHBMTyzbdwQ help omg please????

[phxyvi]

Haven’t really gotten a correct? evaluation of how this could be made fair/ is it fair?

And i’ve gotten 2 opposite opinions on this, could I get one more?

I’d like opinions on this one if possible

thank you in advance

The C$ trade,nons go for 1050 at the least so they’d be under by just under a hundred C$

Personally I value them @ 1200 because that’s what you’re realistically gonna have to pay for one just ballparking it.
So I dont think I would take it.
Unless you happen to want C$ right now, it’s best to wait and sell them individually for s better price

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83899307&userid=915355&signature=Wpax2rsAGsZsHBMTyzbdwQ help omg please????

Don’t know what the skelly pps is up for but the GWJ goes for a solid non, and the holly can go from 1-2 (usually about 1 if you’re stingy or 1.5 if you’re reasonable)
The gwj Is also a pain to trade away even though it’s a p cute pet, so keep that in mind.

So unfair to you?