The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[librarycat]

Sorry for bothering you guys but i'm really tired today and can't figure out if trades are fair right now unless they're straight swaps

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222065&userid=832619&signature=WQB1VkT1ldYkXf2v5fN4GA

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222065&userid=832619&signature=WQB1VkT1ldYkXf2v5fN4GA

[kelly324]

Need help ASAP please!
Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222803&userid=906324&signature=bj2NVudmh-PBxDVdP8VZUQ

[Shy_Insight]

Need help ASAP please!
Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222803&userid=906324&signature=bj2NVudmh-PBxDVdP8VZUQ

I'd say it's probably overpay on their part, but it depends how you value the tokens.

[~.mango.~]

Need help ASAP please!
Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222803&userid=906324&signature=bj2NVudmh-PBxDVdP8VZUQ

This is very unfair to them so it’s up to you whether you want to accept or not. There is a lot of demand for tokens right now but it’s really up to you as to what you value more

[Lucikan]

Could I get an opinion on this?

Thank you in advance!

I believe you would be overpaying. Especially if you consider the demand for the august PPS lion. Though I would get a second opinion because I'm not entirely sure how much you would be overpaying

Thank you! Could I get one more opinion? ^^
Also this one too?

[Takk]

I am currently auctioning off a complete set of horsehair wigs from the medieval faire event. Would this be a good bid for them? I feel like it is but thought I would get a second opinion :) Any help would be greatly appreciated <3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=74160713&userid=116838&signature=53Cd8tdQ_EyruCUqlW7Vfw

Unfortunately there's no easy way to value items, so it's kind a hard to say. I'd value each wig myself around an early-mid '10 uncommon, maybe a tad more. They have about 7 '09 rares worth of things on their side, it looks like a solid offer but idk about fair for sure ^^"

Sorry for bothering you guys but i'm really tired today and can't figure out if trades are fair right now unless they're straight swaps

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222065&userid=832619&signature=WQB1VkT1ldYkXf2v5fN4GA

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74222065&userid=832619&signature=WQB1VkT1ldYkXf2v5fN4GA

Posted the same link twice
Looks ok to me, depends on if you feel that 2 commons = an uncommon. At most I'd only add one more recent common, but again that depends on how you 'break down' rarities

[Silver Pandorica]

Hi everyone! My partner and I really need some help here lol. So, I am offering the list pets here + 100C$ for their entire group here. We're kind of at a loss as to whether or not its fair to both sides? If it isn't, what can be done to make it fair? Thank you!

Don’t want to keep them waiting :’)

Your list pets + 100C$ are worth roughly 26 mid advents or 156-208 rares '09. Do you know how much is their group worth?

thank you thank you oof
The amount of rares from each year is listed here!
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=40&t=3868662&p=119913804#p119913604

[Fertseshoy Getes]

I've got another trade, but I am unsure. Thank you for help in advance

Trade

[Macabre.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74219621&userid=653516&signature=ryCm2et-4p1ou1DmcEhkyQ

If I remember correctly a store pet is worth an '09 rare but I haven't been on in the last two years or so and i'm unsure of the items worth. thanks<3

[popping star]

Opinions on this trade?
I already accepted, but I want to know how good of a trade it was. c: