by winkatuck » Mon Aug 22, 2016 4:18 pm
Sorry for the long wait on this judging! While there were few completed forms, those that were, were very well done. The personal section of everyone's forms did not count towards judging. What me and a few guest judges looked for were how well the character was fleshed out using personality, relationships, history, art and story. The choice was very hard, but I hope you all agree with who we've picked.
First I'd like to give a huge shout out to both Hnai and Bettalong, your forms were very well laid out and had lovely elements of story and art. But, me and my judges felt that your forms lacked the true depth we were looking for character wise. There was a clear premise for both characters but neither had that "realistic edge" so to speak.
You'll both be awarded 10 copper for the effort and time you have both put in your forms. I suspect that the next 100 will also reward as much copper for those who try hard enough ;3
And for our winner, we came to an agreement on Karkat Vantas! Your content of your form really spoke to us and told us what we needed to know about the character. It was a very close call between your form and Bettalong's. While we felt Betta's story was much more entertaining to read, your story furthered the character's motives, helping us to better see who they were. Zacharie should have you added soon.
Thank you all for trying and I hope to see you guys keep trying for future GGs! <33