The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[bnom]

So I'm auctioning off my Black Advent, and I was wondering which bid would be the best?
Here they are:
xxxxxx
xxxxxxx
xxxxxx +this

[kamelgirl]

helphelphelp I hate List trades, they jump all over the place and terrify me D:

[Erwin Smith]

Trade

This is unfair to me right?
I did edit the balloon dog out and would like to know if the trade would be fair with just the angel advent? (demand included)

Even demand wise the Angel advent is fine considering the Orange cerb is worth a balloon dog and not the red

Very unfair to you. I agree with the above about the demand, though demand flucturates daily so normally when this kind of trade occurs, demand can impact on the answer. It also should be notied that the Red Cerb's position on the List is changing, so as of right now, even the Angel Advent is drastically unfair for the Cerb without demand.
We cannot pinpoint what demand is, so that remains up to the trader and partner.

helphelphelp I hate List trades, they jump all over the place and terrify me D:

It's fine, relax. We're here to help.
Unfair to them by 1 '09 rare I believe.

[Firedancer77]

These are all for my auction, can I get opinions?

Number One
Number Two
Number Three

Opinions? These are all Advent List Pets, the tier stated in their name.

[lucifer morningstar]

So I'm auctioning off my Black Advent, and I was wondering which bid would be the best?
Here they are:
xxxxxx
xxxxxxx
xxxxxx +this

First one, the dark leo is a tier swap, although more people are after the BA. The second one looks unfair to you. The third looks the best as the speckled rat is on the main list, along with a few a few advents and a mid september.

[Erwin Smith]

So I'm auctioning off my Black Advent, and I was wondering which bid would be the best?
Here they are:
xxxxxx
xxxxxxx
xxxxxx +this

These answers are not including the demand of the Black Advent.
First trade is unfair to them by the rest of the pets they have with the Dark Leopard.
I believe the second trade is unfair to you.
The third trade is unfair to them drastically.

Demand taken into consideration.
First trade is unfair to you because Dark Leopards do not straight up swap for Black advents.
Second trade is really unfair to you.
Third trade is an overpay on their behalf. It is up to you to determine if that is demand worth or overpay worth, we can't decide that.
-Whoop ninja'd-

[leebee]

are these fair.. because I don't think the advents make up the gap between the BEG & CEG. If it is fair what trade is better demand-wise?
trade 1
trade 2

[Takk]

These are all for my auction, can I get opinions?

Number One
Number Two
Number Three

Opinions? These are all Advent List Pets, the tier stated in their name.

All are either fair or unfair to them, bottom advents are worth 3 '09 rares and the red-front is worth 5 '09 rares and an '09 uncommon

[Firedancer77]

These are all for my auction, can I get opinions?

Number One
Number Two
Number Three

Opinions? These are all Advent List Pets, the tier stated in their name.

All are either fair or unfair to them, bottom advents are worth 3 '09 rares and the red-front is worth 5 '09 rares and an '09 uncommon

What do you mean by "fair or unfair to them"? And if that's the case, I think I may just keep the pets I have. Their offers aren't exactly what I was looking for.

[kamelgirl]

helphelphelp I hate List trades, they jump all over the place and terrify me D: