The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 740]

[BubbleAndFizz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HMUKOm6omQ

Fair?

[Kevinsaurus]

Caution: VERY BIG TRADE.

Anyone know what would be fair for the pets on their side?
I will reward help as I guess it's really hard to determine what's fair.
Thanks! ;w;

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... A8lKTiEVaQ

NTN

WELL I saw the UR apple in there so that automatically makes it worth more than the three advents you have combined c:
There are about...44 other rares in there from what I counted [I may have missed some in the middle. I just counted '09 ones. ^^"]

The early '09 ones equate to about a mid advent from my knowledge.
I'd say the rest of those rares would be another 4ish mid advents.
[Last I remember 7 Early '09 rares = a Mid and then like 9 later rares = Mid advent (like late '09 maybe early '10)] SO there's five putting you at a Red rose.

I don't know how many uncommons there are in there, but since uncommons equal recent rares, [like older uncommons. Since a 2012 rare (say white howling werewolf PPS) was worth a mid '10 uncommon] So you probably have other rares in there equating to mid advents as well c: <3

I'd say that the UR cat should probably be enough on it's own from what I can see.
I searched the Rares list for information about where the UR Cat is worth approximately now [the blue 2012 one]



If you dont want to 'overpay' then wait until it gets added to the list ^.^ The Ur cat goes for anything between a red toxic and a blue balloon dog. There is no way to tell you where exactly it will be placed on the list and it wont get added until at least a few more months.

You can never know for sure how many blue ur cats are in circulation, i have no idea where you got that number ^.^ Some have found forever-homes already, some are still being traded. So, basically, if you are afraid you'll overpay, wait until it gets added.


^ April 6th



This is probably too early to discuss the new URs, but I just want to record that the UR Blue Cat seems to be settling around the Yellow/Green Tox line at the moment. A lot of people seem to be paying around that for it. Here's a trade from Dec 18: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pYA0kEtnTA
Just a record of its activity in early 2013


This was February c:

Please do get another opinion though. ^^
That's just what I've thought based on the math I can do myself without doing mass worth with uncommons ^^
If you'd like a better answer I suggest you PM Kevinasaurus or DaDwarf for more exact answers ^^ <3
- Cole

I would have to agree^^ DEFINITELY contact DaDwarf, Kevin, or ~ t r o u b l e ~. They will definitely be able to help you. As far as my opinion goes, I would think it would be slightly unfair to you, but considering not knowing what the '12 UR cat's value will come out as, Im not completely sure.

1) The offer is extremely unfair to you first of all.
2) Everything on their side at the moment amounts up to roughly a value that settles in between that of a blue/pink balloon and a rainbow mane. The range for UR Cat trading is still rather unstable. I can tell you for sure that they don't go for as high as red toxics anymore (except for the extreme cases in which somebody really wants one). A number of people are insistent on paying balloons for them, some are more willing to pay more. The general range is a balloon to a low (green/yellow) toxic at the moment, which the general value leaning more towards the balloon value than the low toxic value. Given that notion, if you value the UR Cat at basically a balloon (sort of considered it's low point in value at the moment), then the UR Cat + blood dog + christmas tree dog together are fair for everything on their side. If you value the UR Cat potentially anything higher, it'd be overpay for just a UR Cat alone. Nevertheless, at least take everything off your side except the UR Cat + blood dog + christmas tree dog, if not more.

[Wolf's Spirit]

Is this one fair demand wise? (ignore the horse and uncommon dogs)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UlVMTDYYVQ

And I need an opinion on this trade as well... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zqdb5XSu_A

And this:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WIZ3y2YaPw

[BubbleAndFizz]

Hello
Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B2xzt7RQeQ

Unfair to you, the store dog is worth 20 C$, the two rares worth 15 C$ each, and the uncommon worth 5C$

About 55C$ would be fair.
I'd accept no less than 50 C$.

[BubbleAndFizz]

hzello,
is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... f7UB-42bGw

Unfair to C$

thank you,by how much?

I'd say the PPS malk egg is worth 15C$

[Kallico]

Is this fair? I can't help but feel like my birthday dog would be worth more than their dog.

[Animal crossing♥]

Actually, I'd consider it a fair trade.

thank you all for tell me the worth:D

[Duck2900]

Is this fair? I can't help but feel like my birthday dog would be worth more than their dog.

3 month rule, unfair to you

[Wolf's Spirit]

Is this one fair demand wise? (ignore the horse and uncommon dogs)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UlVMTDYYVQ

And I need an opinion on this trade as well... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zqdb5XSu_A

And this:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WIZ3y2YaPw

[BubbleAndFizz]

Is this fair? I can't help but feel like my birthday dog would be worth more than their dog.

3 month rule, unfair to you

Yeah, I agree. If they added a good uncommon (2010 or older) it would balance out