The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 740]

[heartsong]

Is this one fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UlVMTDYYVQ

Maybe slightly unfair to them. The two very rares are a month apart and not on the rares list. They're trying to make up for the difference in date of the uncommons by offering two late uncommons. Dogs do generally have better demand that horses.

[Piera]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... e8AlRZha9g
Is this fair?
All the items add up to 16 c$

[Lake Petal]

UR '09 dog + ___ = Purple tox?

[Wolf's Spirit]

Is this one fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UlVMTDYYVQ

Maybe slightly unfair to them. The two very rares are a month apart and not on the rares list. They're trying to make up for the difference in date of the uncommons by offering two late uncommons. Dogs do generally have better demand that horses.

Could I please have a second opinion? Please ignore the horse and uncommon dogs, they don't really matter to me (I'm probably going to remove them, just focusing on the quality of the dogs)

And I need an opinion on this trade as well... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Zqdb5XSu_A

Edit: need help with this third trade as well...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WIZ3y2YaPw

[November.Fox]

UR '09 dog + ___ = Purple tox?

From my experience with a Purple Toxic it could probably get another '09 UR for it if you found the right person. Though I believe it's a bit unfair to the Purple Toxic, considering demand, that'd be their best bet, in my opinion. Rarity wise though you'll want a second opnion ^^'

[Solloby]

UR '09 dog + ___ = Purple tox?

A Sorbet and a Wolf PPS? Definitely double check that; I'm guessing the 09 UR is valued halfway between green & red tox but that may not be correct. Either way, Purple Toxic has a fair gap between it and the lines below (I was told it's worth 7 balloon dogs; a sorbet is worth 4).

[Cinderface]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EnuwIkEQyg
Is this fair?

[mikayla22]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Z_pIlfasHA

I'd double check with someone else, but I'd say this is really unfair to the horse... The store pets are worth about a good '09 rare, and the c$ a little less than that... The horse is an old re-releas that is on the rares list, so definatly not fair.

Thanks
Could I please have a second opinion?

[gabsc]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Z_pIlfasHA

I'd double check with someone else, but I'd say this is really unfair to the horse... The store pets are worth about a good '09 rare, and the c$ a little less than that... The horse is an old re-releas that is on the rares list, so definatly not fair.

Thanks
Could I please have a second opinion?

I'd say definitely unfair to the horse.

[Lake Petal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Z_pIlfasHA

I'd double check with someone else, but I'd say this is really unfair to the horse... The store pets are worth about a good '09 rare, and the c$ a little less than that... The horse is an old re-releas that is on the rares list, so definatly not fair.

Thanks
Could I please have a second opinion?

I'd say definitely unfair to the horse.[/quote]

Please do not give false information. Celestial PPS are going for 60 C$, so I'd say unfair to the C$ side.