The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 457]

[victoriasnowball]

Is this fair?They have the items and the boar

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u7oEebuEtA

oh, and about how many 09-08 rares/2010 rare ponies and moon rats would equal a:
1. Hollyfox dog
2. BMD
3. Cerberus (red)
4. Cerberus (Orange)
5. Joker dog
6. UR cat?

Its fine if you could only answer a few or 1 any help is MUCH appreciated C:

[November.Fox]

Fair? If not, what needs to be added/removed?

With demand, unfair to you by about 3-4 mid advents. But you should probably get another opinion on that.

Thanks! ^^; Any other opinions?

[hojo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WlCD3kYpOA
Is this fair? If not, what need to be added?

[badghostie.]

Would a 2008 rare be fair for a 2009 very rare? :3

Thanks for any help given~

[johnny dude]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WAH5ZrGraA
Would this be fair? c:

[answrs]

I'd really appreciate some input on a couple of trades. Thank you for any advice given. ^-^

Pet trades:
#1 - Pretty sure it's good, but the aussie seems to be pretty popular lately, so idk.
#2 - I have zero idea how much the tree dog's worth has settled around, but the stores I know are around a late 10/early 11 rare.

Item trades: (notes are based on Items Guide thread)
#3 - full pumpkin set is apparently a mid 09 rare, balloon is mid 10 unc, not sure what half a set would be.
#4 - wings are an Oct/Nov 08 each, flower bracelet is mid 09 rare (pretty sure it's unfair to me, but confirmation would be nice)
#5 - based on items guide, the items are worth 2 Nov 08 rares + 1 early 09 rare + 2 mid 09 rares + 6 late 09 rares

[CarrotsEatChu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24840461&userid=293490&signature=7k9aN7kdFU2_WAH5ZrGraA
Would this be fair? c:

No, that horse is on the advent list..

[♥Sterek♥]

Would a 2008 rare be fair for a 2009 very rare? :3

Thanks for any help given~

Depends on the pets, do you have a trade link? ^^

[Patch.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24840461&userid=293490&signature=7k9aN7kdFU2_WAH5ZrGraA
Would this be fair? c:

No, that horse is on the advent list..

I agree that it's unfair to horse, but you can use non-list pets to get on the List.

[LittleTinyBerry]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L5kQJUnbmQ
Would their side be fair for a mid-september list pet?
Thanks.