New Thread please lock <3

[Candied Snow]

is this fair?
and this too

I'm not sure about the first one. If anything, it would either be fair or unfair to the Dogtag bunny, but get another opinion.
For the second one, unfair to you. Just the Advent on your side is enough for their Cookie Advent.

thanks and about the first one their bunny is an '09 is it still unfair to me?
and is this one fair or not?

First one seems fair, the bunnies based on older CS dogs are usually worth the same, not including the joker and butterbuns.
The other one I think its slightly unfair to you, the bunny is worth a common advent.

[yumekari]

Are any of these fair? Thanks!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lMppvOzFCQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EZqIRGkWpg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Xe7e-LmXkg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -xdbMpMyCg

Trade one: Unfair to you, I think. Get another opinion.
Trade two: Unfair to you. Definitely.
Trade three: Not sure.
Trade four. Unfair to you.

Thanks! Any second opinions on any? ^^

[hamstersrule9912399]

First one seems fair, the bunnies based on older CS dogs are usually worth the same, not including the joker and butterbuns.
The other one I think its slightly unfair to you, the bunny is worth a common advent.

thanks what about the last one?

[Eleski]

quote="Tui"]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10414739&userid=73229&signature=O47y-anMOXHQjDf00qbhgg
Music note Koi vs Rainbow draft. Unfair to koi right?

Rainbow drafts are in less demand I believe, so yes. Unfair to the koi. But I'm not entirely sure on it, so you might want another opinion.

If the rainbow draft was changed to this dog would it be more fair?

1.) It would definitely be unfair to the Koi. It comes from the 6th, while the RD comes from the 8th. And the RD is a 'common' Rare, and it's worth bascially nothing.
2.) I'd call that fairish, but you'd need another opinion on that.

[/quote]
Second opinion then?

And this too. I'm clueless with items
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10417685&userid=73229&signature=rHGtZ6NWercezP7klv3x2Q

[Candied Snow]

Are any of these fair? Thanks!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lMppvOzFCQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EZqIRGkWpg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Xe7e-LmXkg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -xdbMpMyCg

Trade one: Unfair to you, I think. Get another opinion.
Trade two: Unfair to you. Definitely.
Trade three: Not sure.
Trade four. Unfair to you.

Thanks! Any second opinions on any? ^^

Third one is unfair to them, since the difference between the black advent and red X is a light leopard/target and the difference between the toxic and sorbet is a lot more, but the demand wise, people are willing to offer sorbets for the BA so it may be probably unfair to you.
So, if your going by demand its unfair to you and if our going by rarity its unfair to them.
Sorry its confusing.
Edit: agreed with truth on the other three.

[iYouTubeFreak]

is this fair? its a bid for my auction [: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3K7aG7AUoQ

[Candied Snow]

First one seems fair, the bunnies based on older CS dogs are usually worth the same, not including the joker and butterbuns.
The other one I think its slightly unfair to you, the bunny is worth a common advent.

thanks what about the last one?

Do you mean the one with the cookie advent for the 3 on your side? If so its unfair to you.

is this fair? its a bid for my auction [: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3K7aG7AUoQ

Very unfair to the sorbet.

[Paxis]

Would I be underpaying?

Underpaying.png (262.79 KiB) Viewed 41 times

[Licorice]

I think it's fair, I just wanted to double check.

Clicky<3

[Candied Snow]

Would I be underpaying?

Underpaying.png

Yes, you'll need to add a bit more to the trade.

I think it's fair, I just wanted to double check.

Clicky<3

I think its fair too.