The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[JeffSatur'sHusband]

Can I have some help on if these trades are fair?
this one
and also
This one

Any help is appreciated!

[VESSEL_mp4]

how is this offer? am I over or am i under? thanks sm for any help given!

Holylfox Dog: 2 MA

Purple Sleipnir: 2-3 MA

I'd consider this a bit under on your side as Sleipnirs have pretty good demand, esp with the right users.

tysm!! ^^ any other opinions? I swear I heard about the hollyfox dog being worth more when td,,,, though I may be misinformed!

[Lex.]

how is this offer? am I over or am i under? thanks sm for any help given!

Holylfox Dog: 2 MA

Purple Sleipnir: 2-3 MA

I'd consider this a bit under on your side as Sleipnirs have pretty good demand, esp with the right users.

tysm!! ^^ any other opinions? I swear I heard about the hollyfox dog being worth more when td,,,, though I may be misinformed!

No, some collectors pay more for TD just as an extra to fit them well in their collections. TDs are the exact same pets as ReReleases, so they are worth the same. <33

[~Heizou~]

Is this trade fair?^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105326567&userid=957390&signature=8WXHws--SlGZHgKMGUm4Dw

[BlueEyedKite]

how is this offer? am I over or am i under? thanks sm for any help given!

The hollyfox dog has a stable value of 2 MA, however due to demand, a true date has been seen in the past to trade for .25 Non. It's really going to be up to the other user how they value the hollyfox dog. This is probably what you have heard and you can see examples of the fluctuating value in the successful VR swap

TDs are the exact same pets as ReReleases, so they are worth the same. <33

I politely disagree. Whether or not re-releases or true dates are the same pet is not where the value fluctuation comes into play, there is demand for some true date pets that the market has shown users will pay more for their collections. A true date red rose dog is worth .5 non while a rerelease red rose dog is worth .25 non. This is just one example. Not all pets have fluctuating value based on RR or TD but the hollyfox dog has been seen in trades to go up in value due to the demand of a true date.

I'd be happy to provide links to example trades if need be! - Kite

[Minu]

It's fair? ;w;

[keayi]

Can I have some help on if these trades are fair?
this one
and also
This one

Any help is appreciated!

1)
2 '12 stores = 1 MA /ea = 2 MA
3 '13 stores = 1 MA/ea = 3 MA
joker bun =at least 1 Non
Total = around 1.5 Nons

For:
Orange cakedog = 1 MA
Clockwork bun = at least 1.5 Nons
'11 store = 2 MA
Total = Around 1.75 nons

I believe you're overpaying because the clockwork goes for so much... Even because you have a TD (versus the RR joker bun), it's value may be increased.

2)
Grinner = at least 2 MA

For:
Elemental Malk = 1-2 MA
2 R Warriors = 0.5 MA/ea = 1 MA

You're overpaying IMO, by at least 1 MA. Maybe take off a warrior? Then your side would be worth 1.5-2.5 which is more fair for the RR grinner.

Is this trade fair?^^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105326567&userid=957390&signature=8WXHws--SlGZHgKMGUm4Dw

'12 Store = 1 MA
Rainbow stripe = 0.5 MA
6 '09 Rs worth (2 sitting cats, 2 lions) = .75-1 MA
Total = 2.25-2.5 MA

For:
Roadkill PPS XoX = 1-2 MA

You're probably asking too much for the roadkill PPS. Either take off some of the reg rares or the rainbow stripe and see what happens.

It's fair? ;w;

GWJ = at least 1 non
'11 R
'13 UC
Misc items


For:
UR Galaxy cat = 1.5 Nons

Unfair to you! The UR is worth more and the add-on to their side does not account for 0.5 Nons

[kittykatabcde]

Hello, uh, first time using this thread and. Help please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105324786&userid=1060238&signature=3WaA5XN4ILuhsST7gZgUQg

Appreciate it; item worth is overall disorienting for me!

[Lex.]

Hello, uh, first time using this thread and. Help please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105324786&userid=1060238&signature=3WaA5XN4ILuhsST7gZgUQg

Appreciate it; item worth is overall disorienting for me!

just at a glance, this is very unfair to you!
Even though some items were freely obtained via events, they're still worth 1 UC from their year. That's at least 1c$ per item, which they clearly aren't offering. This trade is again, very unfair to you.

[meowcent]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105327549&userid=881933&signature=JyenjhzQtf2lh_IcYYZ9RA

is this fair??