The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bugbaby]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91122391&userid=724816&signature=a-uSkqv5lxdywOX3YeZIhg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91121512&userid=724816&signature=UnCmwyhFM06dZ0LcOifadQ
which of these trades is better for my store cheetahs and unicorns? are either of them fair?

[weld]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91124288&userid=815492&signature=DCkh_Z4HAtP9cRLG7Vrx9Q

please help ive never had anything higher than a september list, is this fair on either side?

[Redbird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91122391&userid=724816&signature=a-uSkqv5lxdywOX3YeZIhg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91121512&userid=724816&signature=UnCmwyhFM06dZ0LcOifadQ
which of these trades is better for my store cheetahs and unicorns? are either of them fair?

Straight up cancel that mass trade; super unfair to you.

The one with the kirin is more up to how well someone personally values the pets involved in the trade. It's not something I would personally take, BUT others would call it fair or even a steal.

[caster.]

I'M TAKING THE DOG WHO'S NAME IS RESERVED OUT. He is reserved. So minus that banner dog is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91117140&userid=796216&signature=Ph8SVrvR5rPl7wt-L4M6Pg

players who are not you or your trading partner cannot see the names in trade links like this, as a heads up. but even if you remove one of the banner dogs in this trade, the other one is still a rare, and a common for a bundle of pets including a rare would not be a fair trade, even though the common horse is an older date than all the others.

They must have just got their rarities because when this was sent to me they were all unknown. I'm definitely taking BOTH banner dogs out. Would it be more fair then?

Edit; I sent this back. It doesn't feel fair to me still but whatevs
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91123856&userid=796216&signature=IbqWWGxL2mSKmpqbnrmy_g

[Stumpy.]

I sent this trade, but wanted to check and see if it's fair to both sides.

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91124288&userid=815492&signature=DCkh_Z4HAtP9cRLG7Vrx9Q

please help ive never had anything higher than a september list, is this fair on either side?

Please don't post with your trade more than once per page.

[Reki.]

Opinions on this?
I know the PPS cat was VR at one point and has some demand.

[beestie]

i'm gonna edit this trade cause they have quite a few pets i'd be interested in
but is this unedited offer even worth the old staffs pets they want?
xx

[bugbaby]

i'm gonna edit this trade cause they have quite a few pets i'd be interested in
but is this unedited offer even worth the old staffs pets they want?
xx

i don't personally think this is fair to you, you have 8 '10 rares and even some old uncommons, they do have bulk but it's almost all recent vc/c and the only few rares are recent from the last few summer events. unless you are specifically interested in all of those common pets or something i would cancel

[Elettra]

how does this look? ^^