The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[zero.two]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75125631&userid=275486&signature=7pHhbAAgaT5RUtshQyDB9g

Most of my uncertainty is because of the rare they're asking for. It's the PPS Cocoon from this past Easter, and I'm not sure a 2014 Uncommon regular release dog is a good trade for it.

In my opinion, this is fair. A '14 uncommon is worth a '15 rare (in my opinion) - so they're pretty much overtrading for it

Hello! I was curious if This is a fair trade? I'm not sure c: Thank you for any help offered! <33

This is unfair to the side with the Horse. In my opinion, an 09' rare is worth a '10 VR - So you need to add another '10 rare instead of the bunny

[Endlessechoes]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75125631&userid=275486&signature=7pHhbAAgaT5RUtshQyDB9g

Most of my uncertainty is because of the rare they're asking for. It's the PPS Cocoon from this past Easter, and I'm not sure a 2014 Uncommon regular release dog is a good trade for it.

In my opinion, this is fair. A '14 uncommon is worth a '15 rare (in my opinion) - so they're pretty much overtrading for it

Hello! I was curious if This is a fair trade? I'm not sure c: Thank you for any help offered! <33

This is unfair to the side with the Horse. In my opinion, an 09' rare is worth a '10 VR - So you need to add another '10 rare instead of the bunny

Ah, okay! Thank you so much for the help, and have a spectacular day! <33

[JJdiner]

Trade
Hi there, just checking if this trade is fair?

[Horsesrule5000]

Fair? I value the vixen at about a red rose.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75424938&userid=613733&signature=xzR7D0vN5r8cQHe61tYgeg
~Thank you

[Darastrix]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75125631&userid=275486&signature=7pHhbAAgaT5RUtshQyDB9g

Most of my uncertainty is because of the rare they're asking for. It's the PPS Cocoon from this past Easter, and I'm not sure a 2014 Uncommon regular release dog is a good trade for it.

In my opinion, this is fair. A '14 uncommon is worth a '15 rare (in my opinion) - so they're pretty much overtrading for it

Thanks for your help!

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75125631&userid=275486&signature=7pHhbAAgaT5RUtshQyDB9g

Most of my uncertainty is because of the rare they're asking for. It's the PPS Cocoon from this past Easter, and I'm not sure a 2014 Uncommon regular release dog is a good trade for it.

In my opinion, this is fair. A '14 uncommon is worth a '15 rare (in my opinion) - so they're pretty much overtrading for it

Eh, I don't think many people would agree that a '14 uncommon equals a '15 rare. Usually it's considered to be an uncommon equals a rare two years older (so a '14 uncommon equals a '16 rare) but even then, you'd have a hard time finding someone to trade their '16 rare for a single '14 uncommon. However, I do agree that the trade is likely unfair to the top. There's a pretty significant gap in dates between the cocoon and the '14 dog that should more than make up for the gap in rarity. The unknown rarity pets do make it a bit trickier. The dragon will probably be common or uncommon, and the dog is probably uncommon, but there is a possibility it could be rare.

[popping star]

Fair? I value the vixen at about a red rose.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75424938&userid=613733&signature=xzR7D0vN5r8cQHe61tYgeg
~Thank you

Unfair to you. Depending on where you value all the pets, the other side only adds up to 1 mid or high advent.
The red rose tier is worth 5 mid advents.

[mossmuttz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75423392&userid=789272&signature=vi91WHg7hrkE5hM2Ac1dvg
How’s this?

[Thani]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75426307&userid=509675&signature=x8J_kWcrBqkaDOvM-HfAGQ
Was this a fair trade?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75426307&userid=509675&signature=x8J_kWcrBqkaDOvM-HfAGQ
Was this a fair trade?

It was overpay on the C$ side.
Your pet is only worth 75 C$.