The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Zombilon]

I know their side is overpaying but is the trade up worth it for me? How is the sunjewel demand?

your side is only worth around 1.5 nons, the sunjewel can go for quite more, even with considering demand.
i've always been able to get at least 4 nons out of them

I agree with the above. ^^ I would definitely accept.

[popping star]

Opinions?
I'm really unsure.
I know it's overpay demand and rarity wise, however I've struggled immensely to trade off nons.

Well, I'd say that's a decent trade since I believe that those pets tend to fetch around 1 sorbet when factoring demand, but it's up to you c:
If you've had trouble trading off nons in the past, i'd say don't accept

Thank you! Second opinion?

[Silver Pandorica]

How fair is this? I'm not too keen on rats, so I'd be really hesitant to accept unless the demand is high or they're seriously overpaying.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73192991&userid=774258&signature=73Pee--wdv96rMlhio5_7A

[Hauntednightmares]

I know their side is overpaying but is the trade up worth it for me? How is the sunjewel demand?

your side is only worth around 1.5 nons, the sunjewel can go for quite more, even with considering demand.
i've always been able to get at least 4 nons out of them

I agree with the above. ^^ I would definitely accept.

Ok. One final opinion. Will I be able to trade down the sunjewel for good demand pets? Is the trade down worth it? Would you personally accept?

[elnachos]

how's this?

[serik]

how fair does this look?

and this one?

Ahh, I’m in one of the trades and would also like to know,,, thanks for any help ^^

[CyberNautical]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73205027&userid=924744&signature=UzGuOaIPc0CmGA3yFwJOBQ Hows this? If unfair, which side needs to edit? Tysm!

[Silverstar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73205027&userid=924744&signature=UzGuOaIPc0CmGA3yFwJOBQ Hows this? If unfair, which side needs to edit? Tysm!

unfair to you. Their store pet is worth a late '09 rare and your draft is a '09 vr, so the other pets don't fill the gap.

[yaksha]

im back w another trade and need help with this one too please, which side is fair/unfair both rarity and demand wise?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73204297&userid=720831&signature=UYvQRbvzvtJsYI9MItFZIA

[grim]

I know their side is overpaying but is the trade up worth it for me? How is the sunjewel demand?

Ok. One final opinion. Will I be able to trade down the sunjewel for good demand pets? Is the trade down worth it? Would you personally accept?

It’s unfair to the sunjewel side by roughly 3.5 nons worth. Sunjewels have decent demand and from what I’ve seen, can be traded down easily. If your trading partner is alright with the overpay, then I personally would accept.