The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Luff]

How fair is this trade? I don't think they will accept it but I am curious if I made it fair or not. So please help and thank you in advance for whoever helps.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73195683&userid=776697&signature=ksXMwt5dFNzhDmBTLdomtA

Personally if I were them, I wouldn't accept. The zodiacs can fetch 09 rares each, and your mix of rares and c$ isn't enough to cover that :3 Please get another opinion, though

[Mythz]

Is this fair?
EDIT: How about this?
I don't know id this is fair...
I'm not sure if the Moon Tree dog has any demand?
Thank you <3

[popping star]

How fair is this trade? I don't think they will accept it but I am curious if I made it fair or not. So please help and thank you in advance for whoever helps.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73195683&userid=776697&signature=ksXMwt5dFNzhDmBTLdomtA

Your side has the worth of roughly 17 '10 rares which includes the C$. (Your C$ is worth an '08 rare.)
Their side is worth 12 '10 rares.
However, the set can fetch a low September list with demand. Your side only equals to a mid-high advent.
In short, you're overpaying rarity wise but not demand wise.

[myth;]

Is this fair?
EDIT: How about this?
I'm not sure if the Moon Tree dog has any demand?
Thank you <3

The first trade was unfair to them, and the second trade is unfair to the other user as well.

The moondog is a very popular pet, it's not got crazy demand however.

[Sega]

Need a little help with this one as I'm told by my trading partner that my side isn't even half the worth of their pets. I'd like to know what I'm missing. Thanks in advance!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73199039&userid=908155&signature=vdwCoJe4SIpuuxRHqhHzjQ

[myth;]

Need a little help with this one as I'm told by my trading partner that my side isn't even half the worth of their pets. I'd like to know what I'm missing. Thanks in advance!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73199039&userid=908155&signature=vdwCoJe4SIpuuxRHqhHzjQ

Unless I'm missing the same thing, this trade is actually fair..? 2013 store pets are worth an early 2009 rare each.

[1AlphaWolf]

Need a little help with this one as I'm told by my trading partner that my side isn't even half the worth of their pets. I'd like to know what I'm missing. Thanks in advance!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73199039&userid=908155&signature=vdwCoJe4SIpuuxRHqhHzjQ

2013 Store pets are equal to early 2009 pets. 2 of your pets are early 09's so 2 of their store pets are fair then you have a mid 09. So its fair basically. Only off by 2 months

[zamatsenga]

this one has me stumped, since I offered to overpay but I'm not sure if the store pet is really necessary? Thanks in advance

[lupins]

this one has me stumped, since I offered to overpay but I'm not sure if the store pet is really necessary? Thanks in advance

your pet is worth a late 2010 rare - and since there's is just an 2011 uncommon it's unfair

[myth;]

this one has me stumped, since I offered to overpay but I'm not sure if the store pet is really necessary? Thanks in advance

Definitely unfair to you. A 2017 store pet is worth a 2010 rare, they need to add a 2011 rare and another 2011 uncommon to make it fair.