The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Andromeda123]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... H5OJSUNbQw

[Vylad]

I know this was very unfair to me, but I was curious, what would my partner needed to add to make this fair?

These are also older trades, but I was just now curious, and thia is a different trade also, so again, what would my partner needed to of add?

on the first trade, around three late '09 rares.
on the second trade, roughly two mid '09 rares.

Alright, thank you, any second opinions?

[harry styles.]

how much should they add?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... P2GHtgQ69Q

?

.

[Elettra]

Thoughts? I know rarity wise it's unfair to them, but would you personally accept? Thank you (:

[lady gaga]

-snip-

this one too? I have no idea about items.
EDIT;; another one !!

according to this thread, all store scarves are worth an early '09 rare/very rare. However, I barely see those scarves anywhere and not many people trade them. You'd have to look to see if they're are any active auctions to see what they can go for.

[Shadow2204]

Thoughts? I know rarity wise it's unfair to them, but would you personally accept? Thank you (:

I personally would.
Like you said, i's very unfair to them by rarity. If all your pets were to go for separate trades & you were to combine all those trades together, most likely it won't add up to the non.

I'd also think about your goal as well. If you want something higher on the list, then the non would be helpful.

[lady gaga]

could i have some opinions on these trades? Demand wise, please.

[Pokeilope]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66151250&userid=160999&signature=R0dRKQ_gcip571vPNV5PWQ

[The Üpside Down]

Thoughts? I know rarity wise it's unfair to them, but would you personally accept? Thank you (:

I personally would.
Like you said, i's very unfair to them by rarity. If all your pets were to go for separate trades & you were to combine all those trades together, most likely it won't add up to the non.

I'd also think about your goal as well. If you want something higher on the list, then the non would be helpful.

I agree, though I thought at first this dog was a dogtag! Rip my eyes x.x

[zant.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7H2rBoYbJQ

Is this an okay trade?
I kinda wanna accept but I'm not really sure