The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[KiritoRoyale]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66019490&userid=837691&signature=MX7j5vEcoHy7MTkNhzJ6Og
Not really good with items... Would this be fair? Thanks

[WalkingShadow]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66029689&userid=767612&signature=4ApiQ36cqFSTDd891OdUug

the person took out the corgi. could someone help??

This trade is unfair to you, since your pet is a mid advent and therefore worth between 6 and 7 '09-Rares. Usually those store pets are worth one each, regarding demand maybe a bit more, but it's still insufficient.

[Llamawings]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0jKOIZOkEA

is this fair if not what needs to be added?

[Sorrelfur]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MsI02dNO3A

This is for an auction so I'm trying to overpay a bit, I'm not sure the worth of the full zodiac set though is this a fair bid?

[Alphy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66029689&userid=767612&signature=4ApiQ36cqFSTDd891OdUug

the person took out the corgi. could someone help??

This trade is unfair to you, since your pet is a mid advent and therefore worth between 6 and 7 '09-Rares. Usually those store pets are worth one each, regarding demand maybe a bit more, but it's still insufficient.

oh, thank you so much!! would this be fair, then?> http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q0WEVDjVwg

[Elettra]

Demand is also a big factor determing a pet's value, therefore if people think it is worth a mainlist, it is. I also got offers which were way higher than a mid advent. But of course, since it isn't listed officially, some people might say it's not worth that much. (there was

That's not correct at all. ^^
Demand is factored in, but demand for certain pets becomes inflated, leading to people overpaying ridiculously for a pet.
A pet's value is determined by the list, which takes demand into consideration; not completely and solely by demand. What people pay for a certain pet is on their own volition. Just because a user pays a mainlist for a non-list pet does not mean that pet is automatically worth a mainlist. Plus, some users might overpay for certain pets simply because they are desperate, not because they value the dragon PPS at a mainlist. Keep this in mind before giving advice that can lead to overinflated pet values.

[The Üpside Down]

Demand is also a big factor determing a pet's value, therefore if people think it is worth a mainlist, it is. I also got offers which were way higher than a mid advent. But of course, since it isn't listed officially, some people might say it's not worth that much. (there was

That's not correct at all. ^^
Demand is factored in, but demand for certain pets becomes inflated, leading to people overpaying ridiculously for a pet.
A pet's value is determined by the list, which takes demand into consideration; not completely and solely by demand. Just because a user pays a mainlist for a non-list pet does not mean that pet is automatically worth a mainlist. Plus, some users might overpay for certain pets simply because they are desperate, not because they value the dragon PPS at a mainlist. Keep this in mind before giving advice that can lead to overinflated pet values.

Exactly. Joe Schmo up the street could say 'I an being traded a mainlist for *blank* pet' doesn't mean it's actually worth that!

[karachi]

Fair rarity and demand wise?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XqFFE74FvQ

[KiritoRoyale]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66019490&userid=837691&signature=MX7j5vEcoHy7MTkNhzJ6Og
Not really good with items... Would this be fair? Thanks

[Llamawings]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66029805&userid=819500&signature=5wdmJX7_QnTt0jKOIZOkEA

is this fair if not what needs to be added?