The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Elettra]

my friend who is a coppa asked me to ask you guys about this trade for his BEG! Please respond, it will help him a lot! His username is Warl0ck

Here is the trade---http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63224778&userid=869635&signature=R6tLjb-NT1RFGtqnK-ogXg

They are overpaing. The UR pineapple is above the main list gap while the BEG is just below it. Demand wise, im not sure, I guess it's just strictly up to how your friend values it.

Rarity wise, the pineapple is overpaying. However, demand wise, the BEG lately has been going for nons, which the pineapple never goes for, so I personally wouldn't accept. Plus, UR fruit can be pretty difficult to trade off fairly. ^^

[Xur]

my friend who is a coppa asked me to ask you guys about this trade for his BEG! Please respond, it will help him a lot! His username is Warl0ck

Here is the trade---http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63224778&userid=869635&signature=R6tLjb-NT1RFGtqnK-ogXg

They are overpaing. The UR pineapple is above the main list gap while the BEG is just below it. Demand wise, im not sure, I guess it's just strictly up to how your friend values it.

Rarity wise, the pineapple is overpaying. However, demand wise, the BEG lately has been going for nons, which the pineapple never goes for, so I personally wouldn't accept. Plus, UR fruit can be pretty difficult to trade off fairly. ^^

sO WHICH ONE IS IT????? both say different opinions so can i get a third, i guess?

[SteampunkAngel]

sO WHICH ONE IS IT????? both say different opinions so can i get a third, i guess?

I agree, even the ceg who's lower down can go for a non right now since they're real offers I've had, which is insane really but true, I wouldn't take the pineapple.

[holodog]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63212604&userid=491424&signature=MdfxffBG7f7aNlI64Hy3Dw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RlaBZTzGmA
Any input on which I should accept if either?

[Musicality]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aoOYhFVwjw
How's that (keep demand in mind please)


Also, is there a thread for the fairness of off site trades?

[Sinbreaker]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63222071&userid=788138&signature=YCPAXIS85diEaoOYhFVwjw
How's that (keep demand in mind please)


Also, is there a thread for the fairness of off site trades?

I mean, when you step back demand wise it's about even? I know GLT don't go for Non's.. but I'm not exactly sure where their placement is on the demand scale right now.

And no there's not because offsite are harder to judge in value and more so rely on the trade partners to come to an equal agreement ^^;

[Silphy]

Is this trade fair? I was wondering if I can get a few opinions on this before I accept <3

[LostForever]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 99EUxhCyig
Is this fair at all?

[Lindycat]

Is this fair?

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63226087&userid=833901&signature=TfG2q4oLoBAq99EUxhCyig
Is this fair at all?

Absolutely not. They are trading you a 2017 uncommon for a 2011 uncommon, so it's already unfair. Plus the items on their side are free items and the ones they are asking you for are items you have to pay for. The black huggy monster I think may be a 2014 item, correct me if I'm wrong. But even if it isnt this is drastically unfair to you