The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63225400&userid=798287&signature=tZAZ5_jW3UixzysbDd7jBw

I feel like I did a huge undertrade, I'm justing making sure though :p

( they haven't accepted it )

I can not even believe someone would decline a trade like this. A cinnabun is worth about 2 nons and and their side doesn't get anywhere NEAR the non tier. Honestly I'm massively shocked that they just cancelled the trade. I think the only reason why they cancelled it though was because they didnt see the UR cinnabun. But if they cancelled it and DID see the UR cinnabun then honestly I dont even know what to say about that

[Fwutter]

I'd like a few opinions on this trade please! I've heard the store pet they're offering has bad demand (compared to other store pets), but I want to make sure ha
Thank you in advance!

Well demand is all up to you. Personally I value that store pet pps more than that butterfly wolf store pet. But if you like the pps better, then accept it, if you like the b-wolf, then decline. Also b-wolves aren't ususally that easy to trade off either.

[Elettra]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63225400&userid=798287&signature=tZAZ5_jW3UixzysbDd7jBw

I feel like I did a huge undertrade, I'm justing making sure though :p

( they haven't accepted it )

I can not even believe someone would decline a trade like this. A cinnabun is worth about 2 nons and and their side doesn't get anywhere NEAR the non tier. Honestly I'm massively shocked that they just cancelled the trade. I think the only reason why they cancelled it though was because they didnt see the UR cinnabun. But if they cancelled it and DID see the UR cinnabun then honestly I dont even know what to say about that

Please do not give false advice!
A cinnabun is not worth 2 nons. The cinnabun has no set worth yet, as it has not been placed on the list, but it has typically been going for about 1 non, maybe slighty more because of demand, but never two.
Personally, I think that this trade was unfair to them, in my opinion. It all boils down to how you value the pets. Personally, I value the BMD at a little less than a sorbet, the BA at a sorbet, and the marionette at a sorbet. That right there adds up to 1 non. Of course, this is just my opinion, but if I were the side with the marionette, I personally wouldn't have accepted either. ^^

[xXPantherPawsXx]

Hello! Are these fair? Thank you for your time! I'd really appreciate it!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JbJpNZNYFQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ns8AnWTpZA

1. Massively unfair to you, their side is only worth a '16 rare.
2. Also very unfair to you, they need to add about a '10 UC + 2 09 UCs

Thank you for your help!

[juyeo]

I'd like a few opinions on this trade please! I've heard the store pet they're offering has bad demand (compared to other store pets), but I want to make sure ha
Thank you in advance!

Well demand is all up to you. Personally I value that store pet pps more than that butterfly wolf store pet. But if you like the pps better, then accept it, if you like the b-wolf, then decline. Also b-wolves aren't ususally that easy to trade off either.

Thanks! Can I get more opinions please? C:

[Silphy]

Is this trade fair? I was wondering if I can get a few opinions on this before I accept <3

[Kabuski]

I'd like one more opinion on this trade~

[Musicality]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63222071&userid=788138&signature=YCPAXIS85diEaoOYhFVwjw
How's that (keep demand in mind please)


Also, is there a thread for the fairness of off site trades?

[xXPantherPawsXx]

Hello! Are these fair? Thank you for your time! I'd really appreciate it!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JbJpNZNYFQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ns8AnWTpZA

Could I get one more opinion on this please? Thank you! <3

[Elettra]

Hello! Are these fair? Thank you for your time! I'd really appreciate it!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JbJpNZNYFQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ns8AnWTpZA

Could I get one more opinion on this please? Thank you! <3

The first one is extremely unfair to you.
Valuing a 2009 rare as 2 2010 rares and so forth, an '09 rare is worth about 128 2016 rares. They're offering the equivalent of one 2016 rare.
The second one is also unfair to you; valuing an '09 rare at about 2-4 '09 uncommons.