The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Scatterbrain]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y5-KPLlvnw

Fair, or?

[Kabuski]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y5-KPLlvnw

Fair, or?

It's over-pay on their part
The bw is over-pay for 1 malk dog since it's 4 months older than it, while the other 2 09's make up the dates for the 1 malk since usually people do 09' plus 2010 to fill in the 3 month rule instead of another 09'.

[Pastelaj]

Opinions on this trade please?

[sunzie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63172303&userid=631519&signature=j3B96CH2imbsmI_HrP7MLw

How does this trade look demand wise? :>

[KioloDovahkiin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y5-KPLlvnw

Fair, or?

It's over-pay on their part
The bw is over-pay for 1 malk dog since it's 4 months older than it, while the other 2 09's make up the dates for the 1 malk since usually people do 09' plus 2010 to fill in the 3 month rule instead of another 09'.

The BW is an extended release, and only worth a rare 2009 September not a 2008 rare. The beta can make up for the slight gap between the months (the wolves being early and the dog being mid and the bw being a late).

I would suggest against accepting. The malk wolves have really good demand and can easily get you 2x 09 early/mid rares each.

Opinions on this trade please?

rarity wise unfair to the peppermint eared, it's a 5th tier advent whereas the basilisk is a 1st tier (unfair to them by 2-3 09 rares. Demand wise it seems about fair, each basilisk usually goes for a mid advent (5th tier to 7th tier).

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63172303&userid=631519&signature=j3B96CH2imbsmI_HrP7MLw

How does this trade look demand wise? :>

Demand really depends from user to user. Personally I value the Android at a 7th tier, but no higher, and the light leopard at 2 mid advents. The android is often easier to trade off than the leopard mainly because users prefer trading down rather than up (which means that while trading it fairly is possible, it's a bit more difficult than trading away the android).

[kiono]

Whats better by demand+worth?
►1
►2
►3

[Elettra]

How was this trade?
I just got the scarf today, so I'm not too sure what it typically goes for. ^^ Please answer only if you are knowledgable about items! Thank you c:

They are overpaying by a lot. Pretty unfair for them.

Thank you! another opinion please? c:

[kiono]

How was this trade?
I just got the scarf today, so I'm not too sure what it typically goes for. ^^ Please answer only if you are knowledgable about items! Thank you c:

They are overpaying by a lot. Pretty unfair for them.

Thank you! another opinion please? c:

I think it's a huge overpayment on their part. 2010 Store scarfs are worth an early 09 rare or very rare.

[Yeens]

fair?

[Elettra]

How was this trade?
I just got the scarf today, so I'm not too sure what it typically goes for. ^^ Please answer only if you are knowledgable about items! Thank you c:

They are overpaying by a lot. Pretty unfair for them.

I think it's a huge overpayment on their part. 2010 Store scarfs are worth an early 09 rare or very rare.

I know rarity wise it was unfair to them, but what about demand? The entire store scarf set seems to go for quite a lot; do the individual scarves go for a lot too? Thank you! c: