The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Eaglespirit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y2s4l1PSAg

Opinions on this? I don't know the date of the pets offered. Thanks!

[Elettra]

xx how's this one? ^_^ Thank you! <3

[Eirinnz2nd]

The Trade
Any help on this? The person told me it was unfair to them, and I have looked at the responses they were given from other players. Personally I think it's unfair to me as they don't - from my knowledge - have a single main list on their side, I do believe a toxic is worth a balloon - not sure whether its a non or a coloured one - and a blue rose? Please help me out on this trade, Any help will be gifted. X

I think they are trying to scam you out of pets! I can't see a single mainlist on their side and although their pets have good demand, it is not enough to add up to a green toxic. You may want a second opinion though! Good luck

[pigeon -]

would this trade be fair also this trade as well? c:
and just got a third one too

[zenzi]

would this trade be fair also this trade as well? c:
and just got a third one too

all are unfair to you.
1/ their side doesn't even add up near to a mainlist
2/ unfair to you by around a red toxic / gearback tribal
3/ even though its closest to fair, its still unfair to you by around a bottom tier mainlist.

[deleted.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61487261&userid=859680&signature=JLv43N_XlCNJcRxetVosXQ Is this a fair trade?

[zenzi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61487261&userid=859680&signature=JLv43N_XlCNJcRxetVosXQ Is this a fair trade?

unfair to them, their pet is a year older than yours.

[pigeon -]

would this trade be fair also this trade as well? c:
and just got a third one too

all are unfair to you.
1/ their side doesn't even add up near to a mainlist
2/ unfair to you by around a red toxic / gearback tribal
3/ even though its closest to fair, its still unfair to you by around a bottom tier mainlist.

thank you, that's a great help! could i get another opinion as well to double check? c:
also what would need adding to this trade?

[Svtisfied]

This fair? Thanks in advance!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ar3qY1swWA

[basicc.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61480500&userid=850357&signature=g9VIyzmGdbrrY2s4l1PSAg

Opinions on this? I don't know the date of the pets offered. Thanks!

The spider is an '09 rare from april and the bunny is a '12 rare from easter. In my personal opinion I don't think this is fair to you because firstly - demand wise, the dog breed in general have a higher demand than most other pets and secondly - rarity wise, the UC's and VC's don't fill the gap between a '12 rare and an '09 rare. Overall, I think it is unfair to you but please get a second opinion. X