The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[The Last Raven]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61486804&userid=701239&signature=5ooTLqWEdLQvjf2v5R7FfQ

i see... this trade is killing me... figuritively

I posted a response above your post. This is unfair to the toxic. Their pet is worth a nonballoon and a blue rose and your side doesn't add up to that. You have a lot of pets that aren't even worth 09 rares and you only have 2 actual advent list pets and 1 September list. This does not add up to a green toxic.

[Nira.]

2 BAs = UR Aussie?
(demand wise) c:

[Serafium]

this is fair please? I don't mind overpaying, but I want it to be fair for them.

Thanks in advance! ^.^

[Elettra]

xx how's this one? ^_^ Thank you! <3

[reaptherisk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... C_Xr2NNTQA
Is this a fair bid? What would you rate it? I need to know so I can rate it in my auction.
Thank you!

[pigeon -]

would this trade be fair also this trade as well? c:
and just got a third one too

[LLHBBB]

2 BAs = UR Aussie?
(demand wise) c:

A BA can tend to get 1 sorbet so no 2 sorbets or BA's would not be a fair trade demand wise for a UR Aussie.

xx how's this one? ^_^ Thank you! <3

Unfair to you. The Coontail goes for 2 nons. The UR aussie is worth 1 non & 1 sorbet. The UR Foal falls just short of being worth 2 sorbets. The PPS Dragon also has very good demand and tends to get overpay.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61467448&userid=788164&signature=Z7RvpMk66pZfC_Xr2NNTQA
Is this a fair bid? What would you rate it? I need to know so I can rate it in my auction.
Thank you!

The Peach isn't on the list yet but most people are wanting close to a non value for it where there offer though has a lot of pets only adds up to a low main list somewhere close to the balloon level at the most.

would this trade be fair also this trade as well? c:
and just got a third one too

None of these offers are fair for your Sorbet. The Gear back is the best and still falls short and can be hard to trade off.

[deleted.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=61487261&userid=859680&signature=JLv43N_XlCNJcRxetVosXQ Is this a fair trade?

[Topiratti]

would this be a good offer to take for my UR Cinnabun? I am looking for quantity for it, I know the Bun is not yet placed, just want some opinions, thank you

[basicc.]

The Trade
Any help on this? The person told me it was unfair to them, and I have looked at the responses they were given from other players. Personally I think it's unfair to me as they don't - from my knowledge - have a single main list on their side, I do believe a toxic is worth a balloon - not sure whether its a non or a coloured one - and a blue rose? Please help me out on this trade, Any help is thanked in advance. X