closed! go to new thread!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

fair?

I think that's fair

you're overpaying I don't think the items are enough to make up for the age gap...

thank you. can i have another opinion to be sure?

Both of those users must not be aware of the value of that item. It's from 2010 and worth about a late 2010 uncommon on its own. So pretty unfair to them

[kloppo]

I haven't sent this yet, just wondering if its fair.
If not, can someone please tell me what I should add/subtract ?

thank you, and have a wonderful day

[SabrinaB]

I haven't sent this yet, just wondering if its fair.
If not, can someone please tell me what I should add/subtract ?

thank you, and have a wonderful day

Very unfair to them, 1 uncommon would be enough, the rest is overpay

[gallifrey falls.]

Would this trade be fair to both sides? If not, what should be taken away or added?

[kloppo]

I haven't sent this yet, just wondering if its fair.
If not, can someone please tell me what I should add/subtract ?

thank you, and have a wonderful day

Very unfair to them, 1 uncommon would be enough, the rest is overpay

thank you

[threezeum]

fair? thank you to anyone who can help!

I think it is not fair to you. All they offered was a bunch of uncommons and event rares for a 2015 very rare store pet.

[while it lasted.]

Would this trade be fair to both sides? If not, what should be taken away or added?

It's not fair, they have only 1 2008 very rare (which is worth the 1 warrior cat) 2 2009 rares (which are worth 2 [not horses] 2009 rares) and the rest is just commons and a few rares from 2016 when you have 3 warrior cats, 2 store pets, and a WHOLE BUNCH OF 2009-2014 rares.

I'd say that they add another 3 very rares, a few store pets and a warrior cat or two. Also remove the commons.

[wolf?]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tdAPqoycKw

Is this fair?

[while it lasted.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=56103549&userid=602350&signature=Vv_gmHJYwbbLtdAPqoycKw

Is this fair?

Definitely not, they are offering 2015 rares for a 2009 very rare, which is worth about 10 2015 rares

[gallifrey falls.]

Would this trade be fair to both sides? If not, what should be taken away or added?

It's not fair, they have only 1 2008 very rare (which is worth the 1 warrior cat) 2 2009 rares (which are worth 2 [not horses] 2009 rares) and the rest is just commons and a few rares from 2016 when you have 3 warrior cats, 2 store pets, and a WHOLE BUNCH OF 2009-2014 rares.

I'd say that they add another 3 very rares, a few store pets and a warrior cat or two. Also remove the commons.

The 2008 very rare is actually a 7th tier Advent list, which is worth about 7-9 2009 rares. I just wasn't sure what the rest of their offer added up to, which was why I asked.
Sorry for not making it clear that was a list pet ^^
Could I get another opinion please?