[sheepsorrel]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: cupcake frosting
My Answer: I've actually never gotten anything weird. BUT we go to the same neighborhood every year. Theres this person who gives out WHOLE PACKS of candy; I got one huge pixie stick once. Last year a giant Butterfingers bar. And this year I'm gonna get a pack of reese's peanut butter cups.

[rewind]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username:
Rewind
My Answer:
Well... I've received a rubber alien keychain but... I think the weirdest thing I've gotten was a bible. why did they give me a bible? idk

[Glispa]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: Glispa
My Answer: The weirdest thing I have gotten must have been the waffle I got one year xD It was fresh to the point that it was almost to hot to even hold. Definitly one of the weirdest thing I have gotten during the years I have been trick or treating

[azemyc]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: Wyrd
My Answer:
Weirdest item I've ever gotten from trick or treating had to be a plastic baggie filled with fig newtons. I never found out why the house was handing out fig newtons and not candy, but I was certain that other kids had gotten candy earlier that day.

[Lukina]

☠I have an update!☠
Username:
My Update: Contacts and Lockdown potion
Proof:

treat! you have been awarded contacts!

You have gotten bottle of "Lockdown poison"

[darkenedmammal]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username:
Shadow.Of.The.Wolf
My Answer:
The strangest thing I've gotten was a Frisbee.
I literally got a Frisbee at one house, they were just handing out Frisbees to people instead of candy.

[Strength]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: cupcake frosting
My Answer: I've actually never gotten anything weird. BUT we go to the same neighborhood every year. Theres this person who gives out WHOLE PACKS of candy; I got one huge pixie stick once. Last year a giant Butterfingers bar. And this year I'm gonna get a pack of reese's peanut butter cups.

You have won 9 candies!

☠I have an answer!☠
Username:
Rewind
My Answer:
Well... I've received a rubber alien keychain but... I think the weirdest thing I've gotten was a bible. why did they give me a bible? idk

You have won 6 candies!

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: Glispa
My Answer: The weirdest thing I have gotten must have been the waffle I got one year xD It was fresh to the point that it was almost to hot to even hold. Definitly one of the weirdest thing I have gotten during the years I have been trick or treating

You have won 5 candies!

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: Wyrd
My Answer:
Weirdest item I've ever gotten from trick or treating had to be a plastic baggie filled with fig newtons. I never found out why the house was handing out fig newtons and not candy, but I was certain that other kids had gotten candy earlier that day.

You have won 3 candies!

☠I have an answer!☠
Username:
Shadow.Of.The.Wolf
My Answer:
The strangest thing I've gotten was a Frisbee.
I literally got a Frisbee at one house, they were just handing out Frisbees to people instead of candy.

You have won 4 candies!

New question up! Archives have been updated and I'll only say it one more time, any updates here will be ignored.

[rem sleep]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: Trollish
My Answer: Well I'm not sure! I've been to some haunted houses but none really compare to my own house at night. //D
OR MY FRIEND TRAFFICS
HER MOM
COLLECTS MASKS
WHICH ARE TERRIFYING IN THE DARK

[Zuppe]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username:
Honorablechickensoup
My Answer:
ok so I live in one of the oldest cities in the country so my city is a ghost trap practically and everywhere is creepy at night. I live downtown, which is the the oldest part of the city too so I live right next to a two story cement building that use to be a prison back in the early 1800's. Its a museum during the day and at night after they lock the gates I get chills looking at it. Sometimes if I stay up really late at night I could swear I could hear things going on at the old jail, I start to think that maybe people were just visiting but the jail closes at five each evening and doesnt open till 8 in the morning, plus people aren't allowed on property, not even security guards past two in the morning. So in all honesty I have no idea thats making those noises next door...

[ryuuhou]

☠I have an answer!☠
Username: Ryuuhou
My Answer: The creepiest place I had ever been is My House, Its so Old and It doesn't help that some relative Had Died Next to my Room n-n