~Warrior Cats Fan Club V.5~

[lyraish]

Yes they have lol, I know pretty much every cats background, including darkstripe. I would love to tell you a backstory of other main characters that are kind of unexplained

That would be awesome! I've totally forgotten all of Tallstar's Revenge too, and Yellowfang's Secret. Haven't actually read Mapleshade's but it's on the list, same with scourge.

Anyone else find the whole Ashfur thing really confusing? also, we're completely missing an unexplained Longtail backstory that I can't find almost anywhere. At. All. It vanished off the face of the earth.

[Tendo64]

Yes, Brokenstar is actually very well developed. I wont spoil anything about it though. Its a great book though! What character do you think needs the most development? Because even Tigerstar has great development

Hmmm... I think I would still go with Darkstripe, I feel like he was made to seem to be just a bad guy....
Talking about development, I find it annoying how some developed couples (SandxFire is the best example I can think of) are usually not loved that much but very underdeveloped couples (SpottedxFire) can be shipped quite a lot.

I definitely agree. But you know what? People seem to ship CinderXFire even more. It gets on my nerves. They say that Sandstorm stole Firestar from her, when Cinderpelt never even tried to be with him since she knew she had to follow the Medicine Cat code(It's a miracle. A cat that actually follows it) and she even HELPED FIREHEART/STAR REALIZE THAT HE LOVED SANDSTORM.

[Sᴏʟ]

PREACH IT

[SnowoFall]

Yes, Brokenstar is actually very well developed. I wont spoil anything about it though. Its a great book though! What character do you think needs the most development? Because even Tigerstar has great development

Hmmm... I think I would still go with Darkstripe, I feel like he was made to seem to be just a bad guy....
Talking about development, I find it annoying how some developed couples (SandxFire is the best example I can think of) are usually not loved that much but very underdeveloped couples (SpottedxFire) can be shipped quite a lot.

I definitely agree. But you know what? People seem to ship CinderXFire even more. It gets on my nerves. They say that Sandstorm stole Firestar from her, when Cinderpelt never even tried to be with him since she knew she had to follow the Medicine Cat code(It's a miracle. A cat that actually follows it) and she even HELPED FIREHEART/STAR REALIZE THAT HE LOVED SANDSTORM.

I SO AGREE
I wasn't even confirmed that cinderpelt loved firestar, right?
I really like SandxFire (Especially in the first series) but I dislike all the other ships, they're kinda dumb in my opinion.
Btw, SPOILERS BELOW
Spottedleaf's 2nd death is also very stupid
SHE DIED SO THAT FIRESTAR DIDN'T HAVE CHOSE BETWEEN A CHILDHOOD CRUSH AND THE MATE THAT HE HAS BEEN WITH FOR HIS WHOLE LIFE

[Sᴏʟ]

OH MY GOD PLEASE PREACH IT! Its so true, also if you thinkabout it Ivypool and Hollyleaf are two cats that could actually have a developed friendship if HOLLYLEAF DIDN'T DIE WHEN SHE DONE DIGITY CAME BACK

[redlitt]

[/size]
Btw, SPOILERS BELOW
Spottedleaf's 2nd death is also very stupid
SHE DIED SO THAT FIRESTAR DIDN'T HAVE CHOSE BETWEEN A CHILDHOOD CRUSH AND THE MATE THAT HE HAS BEEN WITH FOR HIS WHOLE LIFE

Spoilersss
It was a really stupid death. There is your point, then there's the fact that he already did choose Sandstorm. Remember Firestar's Quest? Take all events that happened involving him, sandstorm and spottedleaf. So then we're left with no other reason for killing off spottedleaf asides from to cause more drama

[Sᴏʟ]

[/size]
Btw, SPOILERS BELOW
Spottedleaf's 2nd death is also very stupid
SHE DIED SO THAT FIRESTAR DIDN'T HAVE CHOSE BETWEEN A CHILDHOOD CRUSH AND THE MATE THAT HE HAS BEEN WITH FOR HIS WHOLE LIFE

Spoilersss
It was a really stupid death. There is your point, then there's the fact that he already did choose Sandstorm. Remember Firestar's Quest? Take all events that happened involving him, sandstorm and spottedleaf. So then we're left with no other reason for killing off spottedleaf asides from to cause more drama

Agreed, BTW I love homestuck so much PLZ PM ME!

[Tendo64]

I SO AGREE
I wasn't even confirmed that cinderpelt loved firestar, right?
I really like SandxFire (Especially in the first series) but I dislike all the other ships, they're kinda dumb in my opinion.
Btw, SPOILERS BELOW
Spottedleaf's 2nd death is also very stupid
SHE DIED SO THAT FIRESTAR DIDN'T HAVE CHOSE BETWEEN A CHILDHOOD CRUSH AND THE MATE THAT HE HAS BEEN WITH FOR HIS WHOLE LIFE

(Actually, it was confirmed. By one of the Erins. Also, spoilers:)

And, I felt that it wasn't Spottedleaf's death that was stupid. It was the explanation for it that was stupid. They could have kiled her off so she could show that she approved of Firestar and Sandstorm because of how much she loved Firestar, and that she was happy to see her love so happy. But no, the Erins made a terrible decision for why instead. I legitimately can't see Firestar choose Spottedleaf over Sandstorm like that. He's too smart. Seeing him having trouble on who to choose was just so OOC... Yes, he loved Spottedleaf, but he would have gotten over her by then, right?

Also, the Erins made another terrible decision when they made Dovewing one of the three instead of Hollyleaf. Hollyleaf could have had the power to see and hear things from afar. Plus she deserved it more. Dovewing was always being whiney about it, saying she wanted to be normal and she was so immature. Hollyleaf would have cherished that gift. Dovewing is so ungrateful... That's why I don't really like her.

[DaydreamNarrator]

I SO AGREE
I wasn't even confirmed that cinderpelt loved firestar, right?
I really like SandxFire (Especially in the first series) but I dislike all the other ships, they're kinda dumb in my opinion.
Btw, SPOILERS BELOW
Spottedleaf's 2nd death is also very stupid
SHE DIED SO THAT FIRESTAR DIDN'T HAVE CHOSE BETWEEN A CHILDHOOD CRUSH AND THE MATE THAT HE HAS BEEN WITH FOR HIS WHOLE LIFE

(Actually, it was confirmed. By one of the Erins. Also, spoilers:)

And, I felt that it wasn't Spottedleaf's death that was stupid. It was the explanation for it that was stupid. They could have kiled her off so she could show that she approved of Firestar and Sandstorm because of how much she loved Firestar, and that she was happy to see her love so happy. But no, the Erins made a terrible decision for why instead. I legitimately can't see Firestar choose Spottedleaf over Sandstorm like that. He's too smart. Seeing him having trouble on who to choose was just so OOC... Yes, he loved Spottedleaf, but he would have gotten over her by then, right?

Also, the Erins made another terrible decision when they made Dovewing one of the three instead of Hollyleaf. Hollyleaf could have had the power to see and hear things from afar. Plus she deserved it more. Dovewing was always being whiney about it, saying she wanted to be normal and she was so immature. Hollyleaf would have cherished that gift. Dovewing is so ungrateful... That's why I don't really like her.

SPOILER!!


finally someone who thinks about her like me. i found her so annoying, right from the first time she appeared in the books...ugh.
hollyleaf was awesome. but noooo. dovewing is the third one. i mean WHY!!?

[Sᴏʟ]

Why? The answer is the erins not being able to come up with enough brain power to think of a power for Hollyleaf. BUT NO, THERES THE NEXT ARC AND POOF




SUDDENLY! DOVEWING, HERP DE DERP "I HAZ DA EARZ POWERZ" like COME ON ERINS!