The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Seasonal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5521245&userid=34742&signature=IoC3D9PzjZh3lPX7LWgNTA

Thanks! Maybe I could have another opinion someone?

Also this trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3u3SEw-uEQ

Unfair to warrior cats.

Sorry, but I'm going to have to agree. You could get more than two recent Commons for them. While they were available for such a long time, they have indeed been retired for some time and newer members are obtaining them, making their value increase.

[ThewolfMissy]

@Seasonal<3: Thanks. I didn't know that. And I almost accepted that trade too, thinking it was one of the best offers I could get for it.

[gingertail98]

Unfair to warrior cats.

Sorry, but I'm going to have to agree. You could get more than two recent Commons for them. While they were available for such a long time, they have indeed been retired for some time and newer members are obtaining them, making their value increase.

I didn't see this until after I re-sent the trade and then the trading partener got mad at me. Thanks for helping me understand why however!

[Mazzie]

@Seasonal<3: Thanks. I didn't know that. And I almost accepted that trade too, thinking it was one of the best offers I could get for it.

No, you could get alot more than that...and from very big warrior collectors, maybe a common 2010 rare, like a rare draft horse

[Mazzie]

Unfair to warrior cats.

Sorry, but I'm going to have to agree. You could get more than two recent Commons for them. While they were available for such a long time, they have indeed been retired for some time and newer members are obtaining them, making their value increase.

I didn't see this until after I re-sent the trade and then the trading partener got mad at me. Thanks for helping me understand why however!

Your welcome, too

[kirishima]

What about this?

[Mazzie]

What about this?

I would say pretty unfair to the top, get another opinion though

[Coleslaw]

What about this?

I would say pretty unfair to the top, get another opinion though

I would agree, the Dogtag is worth a little more than the UR Cat so I would think the Coon and Noncoon would be fair for the Tag, but get another opinion on this ;3

[Olivia]

What about--

A Non-tag, a Non-Jewel, a Non-Coon, and a Coon-Tail

for

A Grevy's Zebra

I'm not really sure what Zebra's are worth these days. xD

I'm not sure it's fair to the July 08s side, personally

[aleatory]

pink PPS from september vs. ten malk fairies. I really have no idea what the malk fairies are worth!