The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mazzie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8NqpXIdXmw

This trade..but take the two top pets out(ur cat and ur malk dog) and put in a 12-12-10 coontail?


Another opinion?Alot people have said fair?

its unfair i know so

Sorry i don't want to take your opinion because i cancelled our trade...sorry...anybody else?This is urgent please and thank you[/quote]
Unfair to the UR pets..[/quote]

No take the UR pets OUT and put a coontail IN....this is for everybody who offers advice...im not trading for the UR pets im trading for a COONTAIL...so with that is it unfair for me or her?[/quote]

[wind song]

Fair?
It would really be swapping trade fodder in my case, and I have no idea what the value of the dog they offered is. ^^;

Unfair to the freen/white dog, i think ^^

[MerryEaster]

So, what if I take off the rose dog, and keep everything else? Would that be fair, or what would be?

[Kaya]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5365433&userid=109553&signature=dWoacYUSfh7-8NqpXIdXmw

This trade..but take the two top pets out(ur cat and ur malk dog) and put in a 12-12-10 coontail?


Another opinion?Alot people have said fair?

No take the UR pets OUT and put a coontail IN....this is for everybody who offers advice...im not trading for the UR pets im trading for a COONTAIL...so with that is it unfair for me or her?

Okay your quoting system is a little confusing here. If I have it correctly, the top side would be a coontail, not the UR pets?

It's still not fair by quite a bit.

So, what if I take off the rose dog, and keep everything else? Would that be fair, or what would be?

I think that might be pretty decent.. could fluff your side a little with a spare rare or so but nothing as seriously valuable as the pps Rose.

[~Mia~]

Book marking

[Tammanae]

@Heartbeat: Unfair to you.
@Tammanae: Unfair to them, but if they want trading fodder, the advents are likely to go up in value faster than similar monthly dogs.
@MerryEaster: Probably still unfair to you. Apple is pretty close on the Wood Wing.. the rose PPS is what pushes it way up imo.

Edit: @Skeseth: Sorry, I really don't know.. rats are not my thing and I'm always foggy on their relative values beyond really big generalities. Hopefully someone else knows them better.

Fair?
It would really be swapping trade fodder in my case, and I have no idea what the value of the dog they offered is. ^^;

Unfair to the freen/white dog, i think ^^

Thanks to both.

And the one who would be doing the trade fodder swap is me actually. They sent the trade, and I wasn't sure if I wanted to accept or not, as I have what they offered already. ^^;

[Mazzie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8NqpXIdXmw

This trade..but take the two top pets out(ur cat and ur malk dog) and put in a 12-12-10 coontail?


Another opinion?Alot people have said fair?

its unfair i know so

Sorry i don't want to take your opinion because i cancelled our trade...sorry...anybody else?This is urgent please and thank you[/quote]
Unfair to the UR pets..[/quote]

No take the UR pets OUT and put a coontail IN....this is for everybody who offers advice...im not trading for the UR pets im trading for a COONTAIL...so with that is it unfair for me or her?[/quote][/quote]

Any more opinions??

[HeartBeat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eDhxO4AtEQ what about this?

[*destiny*]

Do you think this is fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ABcPyFqU4A

Please help!

[Mazzie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5378066&userid=128825&signature=KPn811DxwyePeDhxO4AtEQ what about this?

Thats fair

~Peanut.