The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Skeseth]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5367625&userid=123340&signature=iL85puSRs25QCAOj9dzWwA

I really want to edit this trade. Can anyone please answer? I'd appreciate it.

[MerryEaster]

hurr
Plus an apple on my side~

[Atomic Blue]

Banana for Purple Toxic and Line Tribal?

Unfair for banana by a lot.

[Cellar x Elijah]

Banana for Purple Toxic and Line Tribal?

Unfair for banana by a lot.

I thought so. Thank you. c:

[Atomic Blue]

hurr
Plus an apple on my side~

That would be overpay for a wood wing. ^^

[HeartBeat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Tcy-sH01Jg

[Tammanae]

Fair?
It would really be swapping trade fodder in my case, and I have no idea what the value of the dog they offered is. ^^;

[MerryEaster]

hurr
Plus an apple on my side~

That would be overpay for a wood wing. ^^

What if I take off the april fools cat and rainbow dog?

[Kaya]

@Heartbeat: Unfair to you.
@Tammanae: Unfair to them, but if they want trading fodder, the advents are likely to go up in value faster than similar monthly dogs.
@MerryEaster: Probably still unfair to you. Apple is pretty close on the Wood Wing.. the rose PPS is what pushes it way up imo.

Edit: @Skeseth: Sorry, I really don't know.. rats are not my thing and I'm always foggy on their relative values beyond really big generalities. Hopefully someone else knows them better.

[Prism]

hurr
Plus an apple on my side~

That would be overpay for a wood wing. ^^

What if I take off the april fools cat and rainbow dog?

I think it is unfair to you because you have an 08' VR + VR/UR apple + other pets there for an 09' VR. But you might wanna get a second opinion though.