The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[MeowTwixy]

Is this fair?

I think it's unfair to them

My pet is way older though. Plus you only joined a few months ago. Can I please get an experienced answer? been trying for an answer now for almost 24 hours.

I think its pretty fair IF you consider your pet as a '08 pet. However, most people don't like trading more pets on their side for one pet on someone else's side.
Although the 2015 store pet wouldn't be needed, considering that your pet was an extended release.

[~Loki~]

Is this fair?

I think it's unfair to them

Agreed, their dog '12 is worth a mid '09 rare and would be fair on it's own without the butterfly wolf; seeing as the 2nd gen dog is valued as a mid-late '09 rare (it had extended release)

Ok thank you.

[Calamity.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51084346&userid=711733&signature=JIuKRdWGNk4iUlhoaW00eg
Am I right in thinking this is fair? I mean considering the rats not so great demand?

im on the other end so i would like an answer too <3

Help us please? ^-^

[Takk]

Which one is better?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZHtyTpgQbw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... W6pjPvikig

They are worth exactly the same, as the first trade's pets are worth the grinner in the second trade
It's totally up to you, grinners have neutral demand as does the Boar and Heart PPS

Would this be worth doing? Or can I get more for the raven dog? How is the target litters demand nowadays anyway? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... G51RtbWVjQ

Rarity wise it is quite unfair to them and we cannot offer you a demand value very accurately
The Raven dog is slowly declining from it's mid main list offers from what I've seen, all the Red-X dogs have decent demand

Try to keep it friendly guys, asking for second opinions is always accepted! Simply telling people to avoid giving false advice is fine, no need to cap lock on people ^^;

[MeowTwixy]

Help please?
I know that this is overpay, but I just wanted some opinions ^^"
Like how hard would it be to trade off a Mint Tess horse?

[The Scouting Legion]

Thanks ^

Can i have second opinion?

Would this be worth doing? Or can I get more for the raven dog? How is the target litters demand nowadays anyway? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... G51RtbWVjQ

Edit: this trade to please http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l4K98RAJxg

[jpmouse]

Whoops -Would this trade be fair demand and rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNb2mDnukQ
-Jp

They are over paying (I think)

Another opinion?

[MeowTwixy]

Edit: this trade to please http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l4K98RAJxg

That is a decent trade. I personally value the Raven at a Green toxic, so that trade to me would be decent overpay.
Not to mention that the Raven's demand is slowly dropping.

Edit:

Whoops -Would this trade be fair demand and rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNb2mDnukQ
-Jp

They are over paying (I think)

Another opinion?

They are overpaying! The striped dog is a VR from '08. The Panda PPS is from '09
The rainbow draft horse is a VR from 09
And the tess horse is from '08 with an extended release.

[Takk]

Help please?
I know that this is overpay, but I just wanted some opinions ^^"
Like how hard would it be to trade off a Mint Tess horse?

I wouldn't say the purple toxic has great demand either; from what I've seen. The tess horse can be a difficult to trade off fairly, but there are people out there looking for one. If you're looking to trade down the list however, you'd be better off with the toxic.

Whoops -Would this trade be fair demand and rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNb2mDnukQ
-Jp

They are over paying (I think)

Quite unfair to them, the white and orange pup is from '08 and VR

[clifford]

is this fair? thanks in advance for answers! c: