The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[asexual]

---> very rare
for joker

is it fair??

Unfair for Moon Pup.

Very unfair to the moondog. That moon dog is worth three common august 08 dogs like the balloons and such, and the joker is only worth one of the more common toxics. Such as green/red/yellow.

[KenmilltoSky]

Please, guys, I need answers quickly!

This? I'm not sure if it's a Moonswirl or not. x_x. Is there any way I can know for certain without waiting?

This?

Please? D:

[Poni]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... A1Jh-eJRvg ?

[asexual]

Please, guys, I need answers quickly!

This? I'm not sure if it's a Moonswirl or not. x_x. Is there any way I can know for certain without waiting?

This?

Please? D:

The second one is unfair to you.
I would wait to see if it grows on the first one, because if it is a moonswirl, then it's unfair to the swirl.

@ Poni: Unfair to the dog.

[KenmilltoSky]

Please, guys, I need answers quickly!

This? I'm not sure if it's a Moonswirl or not. x_x. Is there any way I can know for certain without waiting?

This?

Please? D:

The second one is unfair to you.
I would wait to see if it grows on the first one, because if it is a moonswirl, then it's unfair to the swirl.

@ Poni: Unfair to the dog.

Thank you. =D

[katy;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5175727&userid=62375&signature=pE3oQfjSFGYVP3vM3hF40Q

Is this fair on my moon pup?

Help please C:

[Ushuaya]

Is this fair:
Banana for Non-swirl + Rainbow Mane
and
Blue Balloon for Purple Tess Horse


Please fast! <3

[Chianya]

Is this remotely fair?

Actually, re-releases are usually worth less than true dates

In fact re-releases are not technically worth any less, they're just deemed to be worth less by some people because they're from another year. o3o I personally don't like re-releases as much because they don't line up nicely in my pet groups, but they're not worth any less.

Maus is more correct than I am, and she also has a much more elegant way of explaining things She's right - it's not that they're worth less, they're worth the same; it's that some people *value* them less. I don't give a dang about whether it's a re-release or not myself, I just know that when I trade my re-releases, everyone turns up their nose at them **pets poor re-releases**

Please, guys, I need answers quickly!

This? I'm not sure if it's a Moonswirl or not. x_x. Is there any way I can know for certain without waiting?

This?

Please? D:

If the pups grow into BE Galaxies and July 08 PPS then I'd say it would be closer, but still unfair to the Moonswirl; in my experience, people would literally pay an arm and a leg for it. I will pay more for it And if the pups for Growing White July and CE, then no I'd say you would be getting the raw end of the deal. However, get another opinion, it's been awhile since I've looked at Moonswirls so maybe they're cheaper than they used to be XD EDIT: I saw Atome's answer and hadn't noticed a moon pup - if it's a Swirl, and you get a BE and PPS then I think that's a *lot* closer to fair; her opinion of fairness os more accurate than mine XD

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=4930638&userid=2020&signature=BsYQ0BQmkgVvA1Jh-eJRvg ?

Personally, I would say it was unfair to the Advent at that it would need at least a decent '09 Rare (or at least a store pet lol), if not two. Double check though

[asexual]

Is this remotely fair?

Actually, re-releases are usually worth less than true dates

In fact re-releases are not technically worth any less, they're just deemed to be worth less by some people because they're from another year. o3o I personally don't like re-releases as much because they don't line up nicely in my pet groups, but they're not worth any less.

Maus is more correct than I am, and she also has a much more elegant way of explaining things She's right - it's not that they're worth less, they're worth the same; it's that some people *value* them less. I don't give a dang about whether it's a re-release or not myself, I just know that when I trade my re-releases, everyone turns up their nose at them **pets poor re-releases**

Please, guys, I need answers quickly!

This? I'm not sure if it's a Moonswirl or not. x_x. Is there any way I can know for certain without waiting?

This?

Please? D:

If the pups grow into BE Galaxies and July 08 PPS then I'd say it would be closer, but still unfair to the Moonswirl; in my experience, people would literally pay an arm and a leg for it. I will pay more for it And if the pups for Growing White July and CE, then no I'd say you would be getting the raw end of the deal. However, get another opinion, it's been awhile since I've looked at Moonswirls so maybe they're cheaper than they used to be XD EDIT: I saw Atome's answer and hadn't noticed a moon pup - if it's a Swirl, and you get a BE and PPS then I think that's a *lot* closer to fair; her opinion of fairness os more accurate than mine XD

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=4930638&userid=2020&signature=BsYQ0BQmkgVvA1Jh-eJRvg ?

Personally, I would say it was unfair to the Advent at that it would need at least a decent '09 Rare (or at least a store pet lol), if not two. Double check though

Not fair to you Chi :3
They need at least one rare

[Chianya]

Thanks Atome <3 Would it be better if I removed the rare dog? I'd like this to end without a cancellation, but I have a feeling they're not going to add to their side XD