new thread!

[Appreciate]

[quote=Appreciate"]
[quote=Appreciate"]

Fair?
1. If I took away the warriorcats, what would I take away from their side?
2. If it's not fair, what should I / they add? (Then answer question 1)
P.S. The corgi is a LATE 2013 very rare, NOT an early 2014 very rare.
Please answer, and thank you in advance!

[/qute][/qote]

[NatashaRomanoff]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=47539580&userid=629150&signature=mz7tUwBmM6UBqZwXsbFAdg
Fair?

[Quail]

This is overpay correct?

I Agree That's Overpay, The 2009 Nine Rares Plus The Very Rare Would Cover It I Believe.

Thank you, second opinion please?
also what about this one?

[Constellation.]

Is this a fair trade?

If not, what should be done to make it more fair?

Thank you in advance!

Its Pretty Fair, The Pets Are Within The Three Month Rule And Everything.

I would have to agree and plus 2 RARES are worth a very rare

I have to disagree, I honestly don't think so. Rarity math doesn't work, as on the front page. 2 Rares aren't worth a very rare. Idk about the demand but rarity wise no.

There is no such thing as rarity math, everything is different. It's not as easy as breaking it down into twos. 2 uncommons doesn't equal rare. 2 Rares does not equal very rare

[seraphine.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DOIBxNHKMw

Is this fair? Thanks for any help! ^^

[Constellation.]

This is overpay correct?

I Agree That's Overpay, The 2009 Nine Rares Plus The Very Rare Would Cover It I Believe.

Thank you, second opinion please?
also what about this one?

I don't know about the second trade, the first is over because each store pet is worth a '10 rare.

Edit: I think the second one is overpay because it's an '08 rerelease. Not positive about demands, probably should get a second opinion for those.

[Cartier]

This is overpay correct?

I Agree That's Overpay, The 2009 Nine Rares Plus The Very Rare Would Cover It I Believe.

Thank you, second opinion please?
also what about this one?

The first trade a definitely agree
And get another opinion but it looks like the second trade is about fair.

[infiniti.]

I don't understand why no one helped me. :C *I posted on page 3 everyone helped swiggetyswooty*
Can someone help pls?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YbrMU7cDvA

Thank you! ^^

[Pragmatic]

Was this a fair trade?

Thank you in advance!

[ImThatRogue]

This is overpay correct?

I Agree That's Overpay, The 2009 Nine Rares Plus The Very Rare Would Cover It I Believe.

Thank you, second opinion please?
also what about this one?

Both trades are unfair to them. The dog in the second trade is an '08 very rare, worth 2 '09 rares and a '10 rare. Your store pets are worth 2 '09 rares altogether.

I don't understand why no one helped me. :C *I posted on page 3 everyone helped swiggetyswooty*
Can someone help pls?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YbrMU7cDvA

Thank you! ^^

It's a perfectly fair trade. Their cat is a Valentine's '09 re-release, and your cat is a March '09 re-release.