The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[LissaJo]

1, and how unfair please!

2, and how unfair please!

3

1 is unfair to the cake dog by roughly a red rose tier

2 is very unfair to the bottom.. the first plushie is worth an 09 rare alone and all of there items worth maybe a 2015 common (they were part of a free set and its noy a complete set)

3 the dog plushie is worth around the 34 c$ alone.. so the rose petals are perfect swaps so the rest of the items are unneeded to make it fair

[river blossom]

Was this fair?

[LissaJo]

Was this fair?

No it was unfair to the shima side in rarity and demand.. shimas are going for mid to high advents demand wise at the moment

And i believe the swirl dog is an 08 as well so if you removed the shima and swirl dog from your side and one rare from their side, it would be fair (though the gsd does have a bit of demand)

[Pom Pom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46210537&userid=663899&signature=z7S_PGRo0oxCMq2SZj5Zow
Is this a fair trade? Thanks so much in advance

I think it is, but yet I'm not completely sure how much the red rose is worth. you should get a second opinion!

Thank you so much like advised, can I get a second opinion ?

[alegreya.]

How fair is this?
(Strictly rarity wise, please don't include demand)

[tawnypelt3]

Was this fair?

No it was unfair to the shima side in rarity and demand.. shimas are going for mid to high advents demand wise at the moment

And i believe the swirl dog is an 08 as well so if you removed the shima and swirl dog and one rare from their side, it would be fair (though the gsd does have a bit of demand)

It doesn't matter what Shima longtails are "going for." That is not an accurate measure of any demand for the pet, it's only what a few foolish people are paying and what many more people are demanding as payment.

The three 2nd gen dogs on the top side are all extended release pets that were available until late 2009, so they are only worth a late 2009 rare each. I don't know what you're saying, actually, as you seem to have the sides mixed up and I can't tell who you're saying it's unfair to.

The trade was quite unfair to the bottom, but not because of the Shima longtail. The black and white skull Malk cat would have been a fair trade for that.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46210537&userid=663899&signature=z7S_PGRo0oxCMq2SZj5Zow
Is this a fair trade? Thanks so much in advance

I think it is, but yet I'm not completely sure how much the red rose is worth. you should get a second opinion!

Thank you so much like advised, can I get a second opinion ?

The red rose is worth an early 2009 rare and thus the trade is unfair to the rose. For reference, the dolphin balloon is worth an early 2010 rare.

[Princeton]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bC-yZI9i-w
Is this fair??

[elizae]

Fair? May I have two opinions?

[Young and Beautiful]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46211011&userid=737351&signature=gifK4pMykFIabC-yZI9i-w
Is this fair??

Unfair to them just one of the cats would be fine for yours.

[Quitting forever <3]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46211011&userid=737351&signature=gifK4pMykFIabC-yZI9i-w
Is this fair??

Unfair to them just one of the cats would be fine for yours.

x;; Agreed ^^