The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[zenzi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46133789&userid=721497&signature=r4kLJ0RCS3kt9ljEBjdLXA

Is This fair? Please tell me what they could add or to my side

the '14 uncommon is not needed on your side ^^

[Simonpet]

I just got this trade. I'm not sure if it is fair. I know that the rarities match up, but I don't remember the exact date Zodiac dogs were released. I would like more than one opinion. Thanks.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

BEG+CEG=Non?

Thanks :)

About fair or a little more than a non ^^

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46133789&userid=721497&signature=r4kLJ0RCS3kt9ljEBjdLXA

Is This fair? Please tell me what they could add or to my side

Unfair to you, just the 2012 common would be okay c:

[zenzi]

I just got this trade. I'm not sure if it is fair. I know that the rarities match up, but I don't remember the exact date Zodiac dogs were released. I would like more than one opinion. Thanks.

the fawn is from '11 easter, to he's worth around an '11 uncommon.
the easter egg is from '15.
the gap between early-mid-late '10 rares is usually an '11 uncommon. the zodiacs are from january '10, so the gap between the halloween '10 rare and the zodiac is around an '10 uncommon.
therefore its unfair to you by an '11 uncommon or so ^^

[alegreya.]

I'm almost 100 % sure this isn't fair to them, so what could fill the gap?

[zenzi]

I'm almost 100 % sure this isn't fair to them, so what could fill the gap?

unfair to them by a GWJ or so ^^

[Clayflower]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gvcT1o_JBQ

Should I do this?

[Don'tHugMeI'mScared]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aQ3UusVK4g

[Simonpet]

I just got this trade. I'm not sure if it is fair. I know that the rarities match up, but I don't remember the exact date Zodiac dogs were released. I would like more than one opinion. Thanks.

the fawn is from '11 easter, to he's worth around an '11 uncommon.
the easter egg is from '15.
the gap between early-mid-late '10 rares is usually an '11 uncommon. the zodiacs are from january '10, so the gap between the halloween '10 rare and the zodiac is around an '10 uncommon.
therefore its unfair to you by an '11 uncommon or so ^^

Thank you!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aQ3UusVK4g

Looks unfair to you
Th pocky is worth an 08 rare/very rare. If you value it as a rare, one llama and an 09 uncommon or two would be okay. Valuing it as a very rare- two of the llamas and a 2010 rare would be fine.
Overall 2 of the llamas gives a middle value