The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[TowerOfHeaven]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46084475&userid=676961&signature=kKtQIqDIdMQorVTTq9g4_g
Is this fair or overpay? Thanks for all the help you guys are giving!^^

Overpay on your side, I believe. The items I take to be free and the 2014 VR is an 08 rerelease.

Thank you! ^_^ Err. Another opinion, please? C;

[Ashki]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46084773&userid=529351&signature=GjGqfsLvJy_TrV4dr-CCsA
Fair?

I'm a bit rusty with trading pets so high, so I'm not sure the gap. (if its even that big.)

unfair to you by a red toxic ^^

Thanks! Any second opinions?

Agreed ^^

[Checkinder]

How does this bid look?

[Huskyy]

How does this bid look?

I'd say unfair to you. But im not entirely sure. ^^

[marmoris]

unfair to you by a red toxic ^^

Thanks! Any second opinions?

Agreed ^^

Thank you both. Can I have a link to the gap breakdown list? (Or something like that)

Just so I can have future ref.

[.lumos]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46084938&userid=653963&signature=6mH6TZ-OLqCcHMhCwZMQVw
Is this fair?

[Ashki]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46084938&userid=653963&signature=6mH6TZ-OLqCcHMhCwZMQVw
Is this fair?

Rarity-wise fair, if not unfair to them
Demand-wise, not sure XD

Please do not give false advice - a 2010 rare (the store pets' worth) is worth 8 2011 uncommons, they only have 7 on their side. ^^

[zenzi]

Thank you both. Can I have a link to the gap breakdown list? (Or something like that)

Just so I can have future ref.

in my sig
("Gap Guide")

[Fenia]

I want to trade for a blue snowflake scarf dog
I have tons of pets on their wishlist but I have no idea how much list pets are worth
so what would be appropriate?
I have rares starting from 2009

[dakotapaws]

I'm stuck between these two offers..which
one would be a better choice in the long run?
I think the first one is more fair though, not completely sure..

Offer 1
Offer 2