please use new thread!

[The Legacy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jclrw0o4iQ

Is this fair

[Guest]

Is this a fair bid for a Malk Smiley? Or is it way underpay { which it probably is Cx }
Thanks in advance! :)

I believe the PPS store pet is overpay for it enough ^^ Considering a current store pet is worth a '10 rare, a store pet from a year ago is probably good for the Smiley c: Doesn't really take into account demand though o3o

Uhm... get another opinion n_n"

Thanks, second opinions? I'm trying to overpay a bit! ^_^

[zenzi]

Is this a fair bid for a Malk Smiley? Or is it way underpay { which it probably is Cx }
Thanks in advance!

I believe the PPS store pet is overpay for it enough ^^ Considering a current store pet is worth a '10 rare, a store pet from a year ago is probably good for the Smiley c: Doesn't really take into account demand though o3o

Uhm... get another opinion n_n"

Thanks, second opinions? I'm trying to overpay a bit! ^_^

The Dragon PPS Would be fair alone. ^^

[Zambeah]

May I please get some help? c:

Do these pets add up to an early 2010 rare/the Smiley rarity wise?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q0OLZXzzRA

I mean, there are a lot of commons and uncommons, but the oldest pet is a rare November 2010 and I am not sure if they fill the gap inbetween.

[Aychemex]

Could someone check this out, what would be needed to add up to the non-balloon?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fv1mko5YjA

[zenzi]

Could someone check this out, what would be needed to add up to the non-balloon?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fv1mko5YjA

About an RBM Or alittle more. ^^

[The Legacy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45602545&userid=649368&signature=zDdHJfOh88bPJclrw0o4iQ

Is this fair

[ImThatRogue]

May I please get some help? c:

Do these pets add up to an early 2010 rare/the Smiley rarity wise?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q0OLZXzzRA

I mean, there are a lot of commons and uncommons, but the oldest pet is a rare November 2010 and I am not sure if they fill the gap inbetween.

I think I'm not supposed to answer this, since I am on the other side of the trade, but if it helps, I believe the gap between an early '10 rare and a late '10 rare is a mid/late '11 uncommon. and I believe my side adds up to about:

64 '14 uc = 32 '13 uc = 16 '12 uc = 8 '11 uc = 2 '11 r = '10 r (that is without the late '10 rare)

You could get someone else to confirm this if you'd like, since I could be wrong. And, I'd be willing to add more to the trade, as I'd really like to obtain that malk smile and I have plenty of extras to offer.

[Lucien Aeidail]

This is a trade that they offered to me. I know it's currently not fair, but how many '12 commons should there be to make it fair?

[ImThatRogue]

This is a trade that they offered to me. I know it's currently not fair, but how many '12 commons should there be to make it fair?

Your rare is an '09 re-release. If I did the math correctly, I believe they'd have to add about 51 '12 commons in order for it to be fair.