The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[~Journey~]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them

[Joof]

thanks for all the help on my trade.
i now have another one and i like to know if this is fair:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ur55jwrtQQ
Thanks ^^

I think its pretty fair! Just decide which one you want

Thank you ^^
Can i have a second opinion please?

[Snowy_Owl]

Last check ^_^ Is this trade fair like it is? Thank you for any help.
Click

I do believe that it is unfair to you, due to there being atleast 3 main list that I can see plus tons of others. I'm not sure how to edit it though. I'd look for other opinions as well.[/quote]

Thank you very much ^^ Can anyone help me to edit it?

[PinkiiChan]

hey! my mountain zebra is UFA. I would like to know if this bidis fair? thx !

[Biparo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... i25kNXNQYA

This? Thank you!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Last check ^_^ Is this trade fair like it is? Thank you for any help.
Click

Thank you very much ^^ Can anyone help me to edit it?

rarity wise the four mainlist plus some would be fair
Keep in mind the beg has good demand and tends to go for overpay

[Barnes&Rogers]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5OGuZmbkTw
Fair?

[MidniteScy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43847989&userid=614713&signature=ECpB4nD_AsX45OGuZmbkTw
Fair?

In my opinion, pets would be worth more than items, but I don't know my item rarities, and am not all that experience. XD You might want another opinion as well.

[miyadera]

How unfair was this to them?

[tawnypelt3]

thanks for all the help on my trade.
i now have another one and i like to know if this is fair:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ur55jwrtQQ
Thanks ^^

I think its pretty fair! Just decide which one you want

Thank you ^^
Can i have a second opinion please?

Very unfair to the top. Earliest items on your side are from 2012, the rest just get later and later. I think even just their 2011 horse would be overpay, though probably not by much.

I'm currently holding an auction and would like to know which trade(s) are fair? Please and thank you~
Bid 1.
Bid 2
Bid 3
bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

I would go with bid 6 it is the closest to bring fair

Bid 1 is quite unfair to the tree dog.
Bid 2 is quite unfair to the tree dog.
Bid 3 is very unfair to the tree dog.
Bid 4 is unfair to the tree dog.
Bid 5 is a good amount of overpay.
Bid 6 is the most overpay.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43846743&userid=13352&signature=q-zU9pbP62WWi25kNXNQYA

This? Thank you!

Unfair to the top. Your green-fronted holly is worth about 8-9 2009 rares, so if you keep just the tiger rat and 5 2009 rares and the scorpion it should be fair.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43847989&userid=614713&signature=ECpB4nD_AsX45OGuZmbkTw
Fair?

In my opinion, pets would be worth more than items, but I don't know my item rarities, and am not all that experience. XD You might want another opinion as well.

Please do not try to give advice on trades with items if you don't know item worth. We don't want anyone to accept a bad trade if they get the wrong idea.
Looking at the Items Guide, it would be somewhat unfair to the top since those items are from 2013.