The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Akorr]

Is this fair to both parties?
If not, who should add more the rat or the other?
Thank you in advance!

[Rei Cloudshift]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance. It's an item trade :3

[indebted]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43180259&userid=672842&signature=ybVaKDDbOVi4uSLnSQBEnA

Was this fair?

Not even close--very unfair to the banana. The banana is very high up on the mainlist and the payment offered probably ended up somewhere on the Sep. List or lower.

[Kyles]

How does This look? Thanks in advance♥

[indebted]

How does This look? Thanks in advance♥

Rarity wise, they're overpaying by A LOT. The green toxic alone would be massive overpay. It's 10 tiers above the BA. The Tinsel Lion and sitting cat (not sure if it's a warrior or not) also make this trade very unfair. I'm not sure what BAs go for these days but I'd say since the list factors in demand and all that it should be where it is: top of the september list, not mid main list.

[Rei Cloudshift]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance. It's an item trade :3

[Icyblueblaze]

Hello! Would this be a fair trade? I don't know the date of the green dog, only that it is an '08 pet, but my vr cat is April of '09. Thank you so much!

[miyadera]

Is this fair?

[indebted]

Is this fair?

Unfair to you.

[miyadera]

Is this fair?

Unfair to you.

Thanks, What should they add?