The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[himeru]

Hi, is this fair?
They offered my dreamie, but i still dont know if i should say yes :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EBCW7eYGhg

[Joof]

fair?
how to edit?

Looks perfectly fair, the store pet is worth a late 2010 rare.

Thanks, can i have another opinion? (:

i agree with this (:

[Joof]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aUq-Bq9RDg

thanks in advance

unfair to you by a lot. your pet is a re-release and it is on the advent list. they are offering only two storepets.

[~Journey~]

Is this fair? If not what side should add more?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tXmDa546PQ

[Daal]

2 '10 rares = 1 '09 rare? ^^

This would depend on which 09 rare and the '10 pets
If both pets are from Christmas, it just make it to a January (2010 January)in my opinion.

[Daal]

Is this fair? If not what side should add more?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tXmDa546PQ

Usually I don't respond to December 18th pets (for many reasons XD) but demand it is unfair to you, since hardly anyone likes nick pets, I'm not sure why.

EDIT: Unfair to you. It doesn't go by the 3 month rule.. Went to the archive lol

[Giraffegirl13]

Help please?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JTYyDFy0NQ

[EmeraldQueen]

2 '10 rares = 1 '09 rare? ^^

This would depend on which 09 rare and the '10 pets
If both pets are from Christmas, it just make it to a January (2010 January)in my opinion.

The 2 '10 rares are from March, and the 1 '09 rare is from April ^^
although, the 2 '10 rares are guinea pigs, whilst the '09 rare is a wolf

[himeru]

Hi, is this fair?
They offered my dreamie, but i still dont know if i should say yes :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EBCW7eYGhg

Please help!

[Daal]

2 '10 rares = 1 '09 rare? ^^

This would depend on which 09 rare and the '10 pets
If both pets are from Christmas, it just make it to a January (2010 January)in my opinion.

The 2 '10 rares are from March, and the 1 '09 rare is from April ^^
although, the 2 '10 rares are guinea pigs, whilst the '09 rare is a wolf

I'd say maybe add an uncommon or two, since it still lands around it, ask for a 2nd opinion, also I say this because it's a year and a month back, 2 rares don't seem to cover the gap.