The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[suzarisk]

Is this trade fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43167853&userid=459773&signature=_UGh5B8bHlGTheWKDxPN6A

Thanks so much for any advice!

[borri]

{Is this fair? I know they're probably overpaying, but I want to know if it's a good idea to accept. Is the UR dog popular or am I gonna have a hard time trading it for something like a toxic? Any advice?

[smokeyalien]

Is this fair? I'm aware it may be overpay, but the cats are in high demand.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MQwwJ66-EA

[Patches.]

Is this fair? I'm aware it may be overpay, but the cats are in high demand.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MQwwJ66-EA

Their are overpaying. Only one of those cats is a warrior cat, the white one in the middle, Cloudtail, so those others don't have much demand, almost none.

[.always.]

am I overpaying 'em? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uzpKKa5xgw

[tawnypelt3]

Is this fair? I'm aware it may be overpay, but the cats are in high demand.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MQwwJ66-EA

Regardless of demand, it is unfair to the other person. Their store pet alone is worth more than your cats.

{Is this fair? I know they're probably overpaying, but I want to know if it's a good idea to accept. Is the UR dog popular or am I gonna have a hard time trading it for something like a toxic? Any advice?

It's quite unfair to the UR dog. I don't know the Main List very well, but I can tell it's more than just "overpay." Also, the UR dog has decent demand, but most people can't afford it so you don't hear much about it. They don't show up in the trading economy very often, so they tend to get snapped up pretty quick. Whether it would entice overpay I don't know.

[Tart]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43168236&userid=631634&signature=jsn2Gucs1c5IKQmdFVbd7Q

any help would be appreciated!

Unfair to you, your dog I believe is a 08 or a 09 vr and the bat would not be lower then 2010 and the dog does not fill the gap.

What could be added to fill the gap?

[borri]

{Is this fair? I know they're probably overpaying, but I want to know if it's a good idea to accept. Is the UR dog popular or am I gonna have a hard time trading it for something like a toxic? Any advice?

It's quite unfair to the UR dog. I don't know the Main List very well, but I can tell it's more than just "overpay." Also, the UR dog has decent demand, but most people can't afford it so you don't hear much about it. They don't show up in the trading economy very often, so they tend to get snapped up pretty quick. Whether it would entice overpay I don't know.

Thank you! Any second opinions?

[Patches.]

{Is this fair? I know they're probably overpaying, but I want to know if it's a good idea to accept. Is the UR dog popular or am I gonna have a hard time trading it for something like a toxic? Any advice?

It's quite unfair to the UR dog. I don't know the Main List very well, but I can tell it's more than just "overpay." Also, the UR dog has decent demand, but most people can't afford it so you don't hear much about it. They don't show up in the trading economy very often, so they tend to get snapped up pretty quick. Whether it would entice overpay I don't know.

Thank you! Any second opinions?

I tend to know my mainlist fairly well ( I actually have it open in another tab XD ) and the UR dog is great overpay for the Lontail, Fox advent, and the BA. I believe the Liontail and the Fox advent are only.. well advents, and the BA is on the September list.
EDIT: The August PPS isn't on any list, so they're still overpaying.

[herta]

Hi, is this fair? Please help
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aXe4wEV11w