The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Erwin Smith]

Hi everybody, this is my bid for a Shima. Is it too much of an overpay or is it just fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JcODfKiCrQ

Technically an overpay by the CS and '09 rare, but the demand of the Shima Longtail goes for more than that on average.

Should I take this yes or no? I need 2 opinions on this please, thank you.

The hoodie was only available for one day and I believe the roses were out for a week or so.
The lunar items were available for a week or so as well if memory serves me correctly.
Because of this, I rate the hoodie as being an uncommon pet wise and the other items in the trade being worth commons / very commons. Because of this, it could be a fair trade, or unfair to you. Most likely the later
This depends on how you personally value the Hanukkah hoodie really.

[.always.]

Hi everybody, this is my bid for a Shima. Is it too much of an overpay or is it just fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JcODfKiCrQ

Technically an overpay by the CS and '09 rare, but the demand of the Shima Longtail goes for more than that on average.

Thank you! More opinions?

[Frankina]

Demand wise?
Is there much of a difference between the yellow and green toxic demand?
Also, is that butterfly wolf they've added a list pet?
I swear I've seen it on the advent list.

[DoctorDraca]

Can someone please help with this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yJ9q99dK2A

Is it fair to the sorbet?

Demand wise?
Is there much of a difference between the yellow and green toxic demand?
Also, is that butterfly wolf they've added a list pet?
I swear I've seen it on the advent list.

I'm not sure about the demand side of your question, but the BW is definitely not on the list.

[Erwin Smith]

Demand wise?
Is there much of a difference between the yellow and green toxic demand?
Also, is that butterfly wolf they've added a list pet?
I swear I've seen it on the advent list.

I have no idea about the demand, I haven't bee keeping track of Toxic demand since it is damaging to my health.
(Ha ha, get it, toxic to my health ahhh.... Yeah maybe I need a break off CS for a bit.)
The B-wold is not a list pet, so all things considered, the trade is basically a swap for both toxics as far as I am concerned here. Though if you think the demand of the Yellow Toxic is worth a bit, then I would say yeah, that's a pretty small demand pay, since it is close to maybe 2 / 1232 of the Yellow Toxic's worth.
If you want to know more about demand, I suggest asking about the demand / worth of the pet here: viewtopic.php?f=20&t=2552475
-Whoops, Ninja'd.

Can someone please help with this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yJ9q99dK2A

Is it fair to the sorbet?

Unfair to you, I managed to add up to about a nonballoon on their side.

[little dragon's Mum]

Demand wise?
Is there much of a difference between the yellow and green toxic demand?
Also, is that butterfly wolf they've added a list pet?
I swear I've seen it on the advent list.

I have no idea about the demand, I haven't bee keeping track of Toxic demand since it is damaging to my health.
(Ha ha, get it, toxic to my health ahhh.... Yeah maybe I need a break off CS for a bit.)
The B-wold is not a list pet, so all things considered, the trade is basically a swap for both toxics as far as I am concerned here. Though if you think the demand of the Yellow Toxic is worth a bit, then I would say yeah, that's a pretty small demand pay, since it is close to maybe 2 / 1232 of the Yellow Toxic's worth.
If you want to know more about demand, I suggest asking about the demand / worth of the pet here: viewtopic.php?f=20&t=2552475
-Whoops, Ninja'd.

Can someone please help with this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yJ9q99dK2A

Is it fair to the sorbet?

Unfair to you, I managed to add up to about a nonballoon on their side.

Thank you

[korok]

Demand wise?
Is there much of a difference between the yellow and green toxic demand?
Also, is that butterfly wolf they've added a list pet?
I swear I've seen it on the advent list.

I'm not sure about the demand side of your question, but the BW is definitely not on the list.

The yellow toxic has more demand than the green one. ^^

[gotham]

Green/Yellow Toxic + ? = Pink Sorbet?

Thank you for answer

[Erwin Smith]

Green/Yellow Toxic + ? = Pink Sorbet?

Thank you for answer

Green Toxic / Yellow Toxic x 2 = Sorbet (Any colour, going straight off the list with no demand)

[lilylobster]

Was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7QZkKvlzbA