The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[The~Doctor]

Is there any difference between these two?
x

100% fair

[Andeva]

I need an opinion on this, thanks. Should only the common cat be worth it or was it necessary to say that the very common cat had to be added to make it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2jKKh2VDhA

[bernkastel]

Is this fair?

Please help, both my partner and I are uncertain if it is fair or not <3

Sorbet is worth more than what they are offering, so i would accept, get a second opinion.

EDIT: Oh that moon is worth more than 2 sorbets, so its unfair to you?

Do NOT GIVE FALSE ADVISE It is unfair to the bottom! That Non dog is worth 3 sorbets !

They are only offering 1.5 maybe

Noticed the edit much? Also i said "GET A SECOND OPINION" I'm not delivering straight advise.
Also rats are worth less than dogs pretty much, so on the second post...
Tbh don't jump in too fast....

[RainbowPeanut]

What needs to be added?--

[Romba]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DPbD90A0eA

Is this fair?
Thank you to whoever helps

[Rangiku]

Ok so I need a few opinions here. I sent a trade to someone who was trading items they had more then one of. I found they had one of the dog plushie items I needed from the advent calender. I added it in and went to my items and added the blue coco mug from a different batch in the advent calender.

Original trade

They came back and edited it to this:

And added in a LOT of old items

Considering they were asking for old Easter Eggs and Animal Eggs from '09 and '10, I wasn't keen on trading them. Not to mention, I wasn't really sure how fair the trade was. Also, I was just really only asking for a swap.

So I edited it back to the original trade:

With the Advent Plushie and Coco Mug

And the person cancelled the trade claiming the trade was unfair. Seriously, they are both from the Advent Calender. I am wondering, was the original trade unfair in anyway, or the edited trade where all the eggs and items were added in?

I'd like to get a second opinion on this. Someone agreed that my original trade was fair; figured as much. But I'd also like another opinion on it as well as an opinion on the trade they had edited and sent to me. Was curious as to how fair that was.

[thehummingbird]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42786875&userid=467172&signature=hfBAJW0iYGMlAZSmW7sIMQ

Is this trade fair? The dog on my side is from the special releases in 2009.
Is the other member already overpaying?

[RainbowPeanut]

What needs to be added?--

[Tiggernits]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42786211&userid=30492&signature=ALUu2VC_p1FUDPbD90A0eA

Is this fair?
Thank you to whoever helps

Unfair to you I think, rats have horrible demand.

[Andeva]

I need an opinion on this, thanks. Should only the common cat be worth it or was it necessary to say that the very common cat had to be added to make it fair? So which one is fair..
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2jKKh2VDhA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6opkcZ9I8Q