The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[surfiez]

Okay, now I have three im unsure about :[
I love the GWJ, but im unsure
if any of these are fair. ^-^

Edit: and one more. >_<


Bid Number One

Bid Number Two

Bid Number Three

Or

Bid Number Four

Side note: I hope that white feb trade is an overpay >_< ive been looking everywhere for one >_<

Bid number three might be the best bit get another opinion

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Can anyone help me? ;u; Please? :]
Okay, now I have three im unsure about :[
I love the GWJ, but im unsure
if any of these are fair. ^-^

Edit: and one more. >_<


Bid Number One

Bid Number Two

Bid Number Three

Or

Bid Number Four

Thanks for your help in advance! =]

Side note: I hope that white feb trade is an overpay >_< ive been looking everywhere for one >_<

bid two or four would be the best
Bid four is worth slightly more

[Abstract~Bubblegum]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z8RrJk2oAA
I have no idea if this is fair! Please help me!!

[kaykayyxoxo]

Can anyone help me? ;u; Please? :]
Okay, now I have three im unsure about :[
I love the GWJ, but im unsure
if any of these are fair. ^-^

Edit: and one more. >_<


Bid Number One

Bid Number Two

Bid Number Three

Or

Bid Number Four

Thanks for your help in advance! =]

Side note: I hope that white feb trade is an overpay >_< ive been looking everywhere for one >_<

I would definetely say Bid 4 was the best because the Coontail is fair for the Sunback and they are adding a Sorbet! So definitely Bid 4

[Kestrell]

*URGENT-PLEASE HELP*

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ELWEjSctwQ
The pet on the bottom is worth an early '09 rare at least, I need to know A) if this is fair AND B) What is the demand for the '09 rare on the top

[noteworthy]

Is this fair? Someone sent it to me this morning, and when is the donkey from?

I desperately need help! I don't know the true date of the donkey, but is this fair? Thanks in advance!

[~GirlsDeMo~]

*URGENT-PLEASE HELP*

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ELWEjSctwQ
The pet on the bottom is worth an early '09 rare at least, I need to know A) if this is fair AND B) What is the demand for the '09 rare on the top

demanding Urgent advice is rude..

Store pets seem to have a better demand...

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

*URGENT-PLEASE HELP*

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ELWEjSctwQ
The pet on the bottom is worth an early '09 rare at least, I need to know A) if this is fair AND B) What is the demand for the '09 rare on the top

demanding Urgent advice is rude..

Store pets seem to have a better demand...

it's unfair to the bottom not even considering demand
The griffon is worth an earlier 09 rare ^^

[Alerian]

Is this fair? If not what needs to be added/removed

[Abstract~Bubblegum]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z8RrJk2oAA
I have been given many trades for this pet, but I have no idea what is fair for the warrior cat. May someone please help me.
Is this fair a good trade? I know it wouldn't be without the C$, but is this a good trade with them?