The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[мσƨƨғıяε]

Hello there!
I've an auction for my Patchwork dog and got many good bids, but I'm unsure which one I should accept...
Could anyone help me? These are my favoriete bids:

~ Bid one
~ Bid two
~ Bid three
~ Bid four
~ Bid five

Bid 2 they have a grinner and add.

Bid two and five are really close together..

Okay, also thank you :3

[bruisedfruit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... W3p4DI9C2Q
I need help XD thanks

[EmoshWolf!]

Hello there!
I've an auction for my Patchwork dog and got many good bids, but I'm unsure which one I should accept...
Could anyone help me? These are my favoriete bids:

~ Bid one
~ Bid two
~ Bid three
~ Bid four
~ Bid five

I would go for bid 5 actually, the grinners have horrible demand right now. I have seen Shima longtails been traded for them.
Ans since thereäs a shima in that bid and some high demand pets I would go for that one.

Agreed .
Grinners have low demand .
I go with bid 5 .
Bid 5 has atleast 20-30+ rares of worth .
Including a Shima LT and a Malk Dragon .

[Party Poison.]

Would this trade be fair to both me and my partner? Click

[Purplegirlknits]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42744185&userid=606594&signature=pinW4XgpqKkxXRzl5RtGWA

The nick dog is not actually high in demand, it's demand is quite poor. The dog you want the Corgi is worth a 09 rare nothing more/nothing less.

Well I know the dog is perfect but for the other two what would be fair?

[Lively..]

Would this trade be fair to both me and my partner? Click

Unfair to you

[J-Hope]

Would this trade be fair to both me and my partner? Click

Very unfair to the sorbet. ^^

[Oblivion.]

Hello, are these fair? If not then what should be added?
Trade 1

Trade 2
Thank you

[Party Poison.]

Would this trade be fair to both me and my partner? Click

Very unfair to the sorbet. ^^

Thank you!
Edit: I don't really mind if it's unfair to me, nobody wants to trade sorbets for anything so I figured I'd try to break it down into a few more pets

Another trade I just received: Seems unbalanced though

[EmoshWolf!]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42744185&userid=606594&signature=pinW4XgpqKkxXRzl5RtGWA

The nick dog is not actually high in demand, it's demand is quite poor. The dog you want the Corgi is worth a 09 rare nothing more/nothing less.

Well I know the dog is perfect but for the other two what would be fair?

Its unfair to you .
The nick dog will end up a Rare from '09 .
As for the other baige pup , will end up a VR from '09 .

I suggest removing the hamster (If wouldn't change much .),
and straight swap the nick dog with the Corgi .

Get a second opinion .