The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[liongamer#1]

I was trying to get rid of this rabbit and the other person said they would overpay for it so I suggested the cat for the rabbit.

They sent this back http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42527858&userid=488198&signature=mtYvr031aeb7DVCoIvicyQ

They sent this message with it: "No, this trade is fair, because, warrior cats which is the sitting cat I'm offering are VERY high in demand, which means everyone wants them."

I didn't really want the cat that much, but I have to know is it really fair to trade a 2009 rare lion for a 2010 uncommon warrior?

[Antipathy]

@ cherrystarluv:
What should be added, then?

[i-m-snek]

I was trying to get rid of this rabbit and the other person said they would overpay for it so I suggested the cat for the rabbit.

They sent this back http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42527858&userid=488198&signature=mtYvr031aeb7DVCoIvicyQ

They sent this message with it: "No, this trade is fair, because, warrior cats which is the sitting cat I'm offering are VERY high in demand, which means everyone wants them."

I didn't really want the cat that much, but I have to know is it really fair to trade a 2009 rare lion for a 2010 uncommon warrior?

Unfair to you.

[~*Reeses*~]

grey malk dragon + white malk dragon = ur malk dog?

What should be added to what side to make fair? Thanks!

I would say around a Balloon + a Blue Rose.
I'm not 100% though, so you should get a second opinion.

So a balloon + blue rose added to the dragon side?

Yes, to the Dragons' side.
Again though, I would get another opinion~

[liongamer#1]

I was trying to get rid of this rabbit and the other person said they would overpay for it so I suggested the cat for the rabbit.

They sent this back http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42527858&userid=488198&signature=mtYvr031aeb7DVCoIvicyQ

They sent this message with it: "No, this trade is fair, because, warrior cats which is the sitting cat I'm offering are VERY high in demand, which means everyone wants them."

I didn't really want the cat that much, but I have to know is it really fair to trade a 2009 rare lion for a 2010 uncommon warrior?

Unfair to you.

That's what I thought too thanks

[EmoshWolf!]

Was this fair ?

What could've they added to make it fair ?

[i-m-snek]

\

grey malk dragon + white malk dragon = ur malk dog?

What should be added to what side to make fair? Thanks!

I would say around a Balloon + a Blue Rose.
I'm not 100% though, so you should get a second opinion.

So a balloon + blue rose added to the dragon side?

Yes, to the Dragons' side.
Again though, I would get another opinion~

[/quote]
Awesome, thank you! I'll see if anyone else has anything to add.

[Paola1223]

sorry for posting so much cx is this fair, if not what should be changed?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... A2tN5R0R3w

Unfair to them

alright thanks, can I get a second opinion?

my god so many offers, what about this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E7BmMOIilA

[ilya]

I was trying to get rid of this rabbit and the other person said they would overpay for it so I suggested the cat for the rabbit.

They sent this back http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42527858&userid=488198&signature=mtYvr031aeb7DVCoIvicyQ

They sent this message with it: "No, this trade is fair, because, warrior cats which is the sitting cat I'm offering are VERY high in demand, which means everyone wants them."

I didn't really want the cat that much, but I have to know is it really fair to trade a 2009 rare lion for a 2010 uncommon warrior?

Yes,it's unfair to you,it's just a sitting cat not a warrior cat tough,but any way it's not worth a rare lion

[cherrystarluv]

@ cherrystarluv:
What should be added, then?

Not much since rats have pretty low demand, but it could go for maybe another '14 rare or an older uncommon if I'm doing my math correctly.