The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[FOUND VERDICT]

I'm not that good with trades...
Would this dog -> (VR Christmas 2008 Advent list 2nd tier Hyena)
Be worth a full "warrior cat set"? (Example of such a set)

Thank you in advance!

I don't believe it's worth that much--the warrior cats have a pretty high demand.

(But, I'm not sure, so definitely get a second opinion.)

a mid advent like yours is worth 7 2009 rares, and I'm pretty sure the warrior cats add up to a fair bit more than that. c:

you might want to keep in mind the Hyena is not an 7th tier (mid) advent.
He is a 9th tier advent, so worth more than 7 '09 rares

but agreed, unfair to the warrior set

[Enuri]

is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... oLto8d1fRw

[babymonkeys115]

fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jJoYEGzuJA

[FOUND VERDICT]

fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jJoYEGzuJA

really unfair to you, the apple is on the mainlist

[arabmorgan]

hi, is this a fair trade? thanks c:

[JayJennyJane]

Is this fair? I personally don't think so. What would need to be added? The dog will grow into a 2010 uncommon or rare.

Not fair--I believe you can't get anything less than a rare on the 18th. I'm pretty sure that's how the 18th works, because it's to put good trading pets back into circulation.

Thank you!

[trickszy]

hi, is this a fair trade? thanks c:

I think that they are overpaying. Not sure.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42186054&userid=665530&signature=YD4jAVHih3CSsgR3Fsj-Ow
is this a fair trade? and if not any suggestions for what kind of thing i could trade it for??

Definitely not. The rose dogs are pretty high demand, the Rose PPS is a low Main List.
If it grows into the PPS it can go for this or this.

The Blue Rose outcome can go for this or this.

The Red Rose goes for this, this, or this.

You should wait until the pup grows.

[Lasagnya]

Hello!

Can anyone tell me if this trade is fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42186540&userid=181994&signature=lqBlqwD-N8IO2EQOjWXFNw

Thank you!

[Celestine]

Is this fair?
Thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zBPz8I8tJQ

[jubilee.]

Is this fair?
Thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zBPz8I8tJQ

Well, at the moment it looks like a gift! What are they asking for?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42186540&userid=181994&signature=lqBlqwD-N8IO2EQOjWXFNw

A little bit unfair to you, your dog is a low-tier advent and is worth 3 09-rares. However, since they are offering pretty early ones, I think a mid-late 09 rare would make this fair. Maybe get a second opinion though.