The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[KaceyCat]

Thank you, Stone, Lucky, and Phoenix. Along the same lines, though, I just got another trade involving the puppy, but also with a 2009 rat I also got today. I'll be holding both trades until my pets grow up, but could you tell me if this one is fair? And if so, between the two, which would you recommend? (I mean between the one for the puppy alone you said was unfair either way depending on what it grows up to be and this one)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185551&userid=122683&signature=gYiM2yXUj5iK2nCBNDTzVA

[Demonking Urizen]

Triclolor Tess Cake Dog + ? = Lime Ice Rat
Thank you <3

[trickszy]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z44Bfstl_A

Not fair--although most rainbow drafts have high demand, they are not on the Advent List, like your Mini Husky is. And, the store pet, as I notice, isn't very popular.

However, you should get a second opinion on this trade.

[lucifer morningstar]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z44Bfstl_A

Looks slightly unfair to them. The pink mini husky is only worth three '09 rares and an '09 uncommon.

[lucky333123]

Thank you, Stone, Lucky, and Phoenix. Along the same lines, though, I just got another trade involving the puppy, but also with a 2009 rat I also got today. I'll be holding both trades until my pets grow up, but could you tell me if this one is fair? And if so, between the two, which would you recommend? (I mean between the one for the puppy alone you said was unfair either way depending on what it grows up to be and this one)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185551&userid=122683&signature=gYiM2yXUj5iK2nCBNDTzVA

Do you know the outcomes of the rat?

Assuming the dog doesn't turn VR/not a list creature, it will depend on the outcome of the rat as well as the month.

[Demonking Urizen]

Thank you, Stone, Lucky, and Phoenix. Along the same lines, though, I just got another trade involving the puppy, but also with a 2009 rat I also got today. I'll be holding both trades until my pets grow up, but could you tell me if this one is fair? And if so, between the two, which would you recommend? (I mean between the one for the puppy alone you said was unfair either way depending on what it grows up to be and this one)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185551&userid=122683&signature=gYiM2yXUj5iK2nCBNDTzVA

Do you know the outcomes of the rat?

Assuming the dog doesn't turn VR/not a list creature, it will depend on the outcome of the rat as well as the month.

Unfair to you since the rat outcomes are all very rare (January 2009).

[TheBlazerWolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5t5c6MUv4A

Does this trade seem fair to anyone? I know that my pet is a 2009 rerelease and I need advice on what to do. I also have another Malk dog 2009 release..i would love advice on what I should trade these for.
Thank you!

[Ironic Equation]

Fair considering demand?

Not fair--UR Phoenix is a few tiers above the non-coon.

2nd opinion?

[KaceyCat]

Thanks everyone. I'm just going to wait to see what they all grow up to be, and if people don't cancel the trades in the wait-time, I'll revisit the thought.

[trickszy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42185731&userid=689004&signature=nqf_4WGb8Wuy5t5c6MUv4A

Does this trade seem fair to anyone? I know that my pet is a 2009 rerelease and I need advice on what to do. I also have another Malk dog 2009 release..i would love advice on what I should trade these for.
Thank you!

Malk Rares go for much more than that, I'm at least sure of that bit.