The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[avanhellica]

is this a fair trade? -- xxxx

(the rat is a 2008 very rare rat species from the month of august. I'm
not sure about the rabbit though)

[KhaoticKitten]

what im wondering is this: I have a red x pps dog which is the bottom tier under the gap of the main list, a mid september list tess cake dog, and a candy cane striped tess horse....if i was to put all of those into a trade together how much further up the main list could i go? at about what tier could i go to?? thanks in advance!!

[booshcat]

Since it's so new, can anyone give a rough estimate as to if a Holly Dog, Non Coon, and Sorbet for a Pineapple is fair?

[Hermione Granger]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RkAZ7wYB7g

Is this fair? I really dont think it is but ive never had as good of pets before

[lucifer morningstar]

Is this, this, this, this, this, or this fair? T w T"

Your pet is going to grown into a very rare christmas 08 pet but its your call

First one, they are overpaying. The punk dog is a mid advent and the rares cover more than the rest of the gaps.
Second one, depends on if you're going by C$ value of the cat or rarity value of the cat. C$ wise, unfair to them, pet wise, unfair to you.
Third, unfair to you. Their side only adds up to a low advent or so, while the TWA is a high advent.
Fifth, looks fair. The two '09 rares should cover the gap between the bone pps tier and twa tier, although you may want a second opinion.

is 2 grinners a fair trade for an 08 white warrior cat?

Unfair to the Grinners. They're a low September list pet and worth 14 '09 rares each.

[Takk]

what im wondering is this: I have a red x pps dog which is the bottom tier under the gap of the main list, a mid september list tess cake dog, and a candy cane striped tess horse....if i was to put all of those into a trade together how much further up the main list could i go? at about what tier could i go to?? thanks in advance!!

About a Speckled Rat level

Since it's so new, can anyone give a rough estimate as to if a Holly Dog, Non Coon, and Sorbet for a Pineapple is fair?

After the demand dies down, the members usually ballpark the URs value at a non, I wouldn't pay more than that until rarity and placement

is this a fair trade? -- xxxx

(the rat is a 2008 very rare rat species from the month of august. I'm
not sure about the rabbit though)

Yours is a list pet so it's unfair to you. It will be a Sept list or Main list outcome

[rose.bloom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42179360&userid=676694&signature=3F44BmoAkbMRgLxqz6ccpQ ???????????

[ordinary pleasure]

;-;

[k.kitten]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Xm-IM0RKqQ



&



http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GfbzILXLZA



Fair!? QUICK REPLIES PLEASE

[мσƨƨғıяε]

Any opinions for this trade?
I really like this offer, but what do you guys think?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42179344&userid=664158&signature=eTTwgC_v-N0TXm-IM0RKqQ



&



http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GfbzILXLZA



Fair!? QUICK REPLIES PLEASE

The first one is highly unfair to them, the grinner is a Sep. List pet.

But I am not sure at the second trade, it could be that you overpay,when the pup turns into a vr, or it turns in a rare and it is a bit unfair to you...