The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Tsalagi_Dragon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h1tfYINj2w

Is this fair? And if not, what needs to be added or removed? Thanks in advance.

[Silverwulf]

Fair? Zodiac Trade

Thanks so much!

[Takk]

Okay thank you everyone for the help on this one !
So I just received a different offer from a different person on the same pet, and was wondering if this one is fair.. If it isn't, how can I edit to make it fair?
If I do accept g one of the trades, which one would be better?

Thank you in advance ♪

Oh and sorry for asking so many questions - I'm just not used to the rarity, demands and all the other things ;w;

Looks about fair, they could remove 2 of the Xmas event pets from their side

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42148351&userid=36057&signature=ylVg3GI0JqURh1tfYINj2w

Is this fair? And if not, what needs to be added or removed? Thanks in advance.

Unfair to you, the dog is fair for the snowfall but the snowballs are from '10 and worth at least a common from that year and they'd need to add another '13 uncommon (or '11 common) to make up for the snowdrift

[Tsalagi_Dragon]

Okay thank you everyone for the help on this one !
So I just received a different offer from a different person on the same pet, and was wondering if this one is fair.. If it isn't, how can I edit to make it fair?
If I do accept g one of the trades, which one would be better?

Thank you in advance ♪

Oh and sorry for asking so many questions - I'm just not used to the rarity, demands and all the other things ;w;

Looks about fair, they could remove 2 of the Xmas event pets from their side

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42148351&userid=36057&signature=ylVg3GI0JqURh1tfYINj2w

Is this fair? And if not, what needs to be added or removed? Thanks in advance.

Unfair to you, the dog is fair for the snowfall but the snowballs are from '10 and worth at least a common from that year and they'd need to add another '13 uncommon (or '11 common) to make up for the snowdrift

Thank you.

[ownanimal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OLX0KJQhbg
Im just wondering, if this is fair, culd you tell me?
if not, what might be for my pet?

[Tsalagi_Dragon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4FBRGOwxIQ

Is this fair? Thanks in advance.

[Life]

For future reference. How unfair was this trade to me? And what could have been added to make this better?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OraZF-3bkg

Edit: Also for future reference was this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qoNDWP9Ejg

[Aaron✦]

☁ How does this look? Also what's the demand of the cake dogs like?

I really need a mentor going into this higher list trades cx

[yazzie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q-xaBuL_sw
I would just like to double check on this, if its okay :3 educated answer only, please! C:

[CandyFox]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42149520&userid=673168&signature=H4UFBmGdUZm5Q-xaBuL_sw
I would just like to double check on this, if its okay :3 educated answer only, please! C:

Looks unfair to the top, seeing as one they want is from '13, and the pets they're giving you are all '09 and '08, with one '10 pet.