The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Kiwilady]

How fair is this demand wise
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TD3D94Ljsg

And how does it compare to a ur black cat and a ur flower

That's unfair to them. The coontail you're asking for alone is worth the same amount as the sunback; even demand can't justify the addition of the non and the shima on top of everything else.

The coontail + noncoon is worth a sorbet or so more than the UR cat, while the noncoon by itself is worth a bit more than the flower.

Will edit with more trades in a second.

Ok they added another green toxic can I have one more person

[Doglike]

Okay, so I have a question about a trade I saw in someone's auction (which won, by the way.). I have a Rose PPS myself, and I wanted to know if anyone's seen it go for a trade like this. I've tried auctioning it off before, but had absolutely no luck. Is this a rare sort of trade? Like, do any of you think something like this could happen again?

[Noel]

Kiwilady: Whoops, I meant to say nonswirl, not noncoon. Regardless, it's still unfair to them.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41658004&userid=672965&signature=_KMuGRfNsr3v1bvCvEPymw
Is this fair?
~feming

Looks fine, maybe a touch unfair to them.

Okay, so I have a question about a trade I saw in someone's auction (which won, by the way.). I have a Rose PPS myself, and I wanted to know if anyone's seen it go for a trade like this. I've tried auctioning it off before, but had absolutely no luck. Is this a rare sort of trade? Like, do any of you think something like this could happen again?

Quantity bids like this show up occasionally for any rares list auction, really. If you auction your rose and specify you want quantity, you'd have a shot.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Okay, so I have a question about a trade I saw in someone's auction (which won, by the way.). I have a Rose PPS myself, and I wanted to know if anyone's seen it go for a trade like this. I've tried auctioning it off before, but had absolutely no luck. Is this a rare sort of trade? Like, do any of you think something like this could happen again?

its unfair to them in terms of rarity. they have over 80 09 rares worth where the rose pps is worth a bit more than 70 technically.
getting that much quantity can be hard and is unlikely to happen, but it can happen if you search out the right people

[Castiel Winchester]

Could I get some advice on this trade?
Is it fair? If not, what needs to be added?

[Doglike]

Okay, so I have a question about a trade I saw in someone's auction (which won, by the way.). I have a Rose PPS myself, and I wanted to know if anyone's seen it go for a trade like this. I've tried auctioning it off before, but had absolutely no luck. Is this a rare sort of trade? Like, do any of you think something like this could happen again?

its unfair to them in terms of rarity. they have over 80 09 rares worth where the rose pps is worth a bit more than 70 technically.
getting that much quantity can be hard and is unlikely to happen, but it can happen if you search out the right people

And this is where this trade comes into play. I know you've already deduced this, trouble, but I want to see what others think.
Also, is this fair?

[amethyst,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41657426&userid=162470&signature=Ldg0eG_roQtWpJl05oPsog

Is this fair?

I'd say it's slightly unfair to them. c:

[RisikiaRBH]

I;m wondering if this is fair to me since the sock and stocking are from '09. Item wise i mean.

[moosetachio]

Okay, so I have a question about a trade I saw in someone's auction (which won, by the way.). I have a Rose PPS myself, and I wanted to know if anyone's seen it go for a trade like this. I've tried auctioning it off before, but had absolutely no luck. Is this a rare sort of trade? Like, do any of you think something like this could happen again?

its unfair to them in terms of rarity. they have over 80 09 rares worth where the rose pps is worth a bit more than 70 technically.
getting that much quantity can be hard and is unlikely to happen, but it can happen if you search out the right people

And this is where this trade comes into play. I know you've already deduced this, trouble, but I want to see what others think.
Also, is this fair?

Unfair to you. Your dog is a fair trade for their malk pps horse.

I;m wondering if this is fair to me since the sock and stocking are from '09. Item wise i mean.

Unfair to you.

[мσƨƨғıяε]

Hello~
Maybe can anyons help me with this trade, please?